fbpx

True Crime Reporter® Podcast

  • About
  • Podcast
  • Blog
  • News Team
  • Making News
  • Follow Podcast
  • Contact
You are here: Home / True Crime Reporter Stories

November 29, 2022 By Robert Riggs Leave a Comment

Othram DNA Lab In Texas Helps Solve 29-Year-Old Murder Case

How Forensic Genetic Genealogy Found Distant Relative Of Killer

Stephanie Issacson Prom Photo 1989

14-year Stephanie Anne Isaacson left her father’s apartment in North Las Vegas early on the morning of June 1, 1989.

She walked through an empty sandlot, her usual shortcut, to the Eldorado High School.

The ninth grader never made it to her 7:30 AM class. Her choir teacher noticed Stephanie missing during lunch period, but her absence was not reported.

When she didn’t return home by 4:30 that afternoon, her father, a Staff Sergeant at nearby Ellis Air Force Base, called the police.

He and his friends saddled up horses at the base’s stable and started to search the small desert area that Stephanie regularly cut through to school.

Four hours later, they found his daughter’s textbooks and keys strewn along a trail.

Investigators launched a helicopter and a ground search. 

Later that evening, officers found a zigzag path where she had been dragged to foliage.

A police dog picked up the scent of her body under an orange piece of discarded carpet.

Stephanie was the victim of a blitz attack. Her black shirt was pulled up, and her jeans pulled down. Her shoes and other belongings were missing.

The freshman with shoulder-length brown hair who had last been pictured with a wide grin in her prom picture had been sexually assaulted, bludgeoned, and strangled to death.

Investigators had little to go on besides a tiny drop of semen found on the dead girl’s shirt.

They made numerous attempts to test the evidence and, in 2007, obtained the

DNA profile of the likely killer.

Police uploaded it into the FBI database called CODIS, the Combined DNA Index System.

CODIS, which became operational in 1999, contains the profiles of individuals convicted of certain crimes. 

However, if an offender has not been convicted in recent years, it’s unlikely that their DNA is cataloged in the system.

Isaacson’s killer had never been convicted, and her murder remained a cold case for 32 years.

Las Vegas Metropolitan Police investigators never gave up.

In late 2021, they submitted DNA evidence, equivalent to a mere 15 human cells, to Othram, a cutting-edge forensic genomics lab located in the Woodlands, a suburb of Houston.

In contrast, a full DNA profile for CODIS contains 20 core markers–or points on the human genome required for an exact match.

Othram’s DNA technology measures information for hundreds of thousands of markers and can be used to identify distant genetic familial relationships.

In the case of Stephanie Isaacson, Othram’s genetic genealogist found a distant relative of the alleged killer in a genealogy database that law enforcement has the consent to search.

Forensic genetic genealogy led Las Vegas detectives to Darren Marchand, who had never been listed among suspects.

But Marchand had committed suicide at the age of 29, six years after the murder.

Kristen Mittelman of Othram says the Isaacson case is the tip of the iceberg of a silent mass disaster. Little attention or money is being focused on solving an estimated quarter of a million cold cases in the United States. “You know, it has really struck me after all these years that a lot of people have gotten away with murder and multiple murders. When you look at how you unravel and find out their other victims. It really is a scandal. It’s shameful when you look at it.”

Othram’s lab is nestled in a gleaming 25,000-foot office building on a serene campus. DNA analysts work inside glass-walled sterile environments. It’s not unusual to see human skulls and bones resting on lab tables. Outside the labs, some of the company’s 50 employees peer into computer screens studying DNA information. A classroom is often filled with Texas Rangers and detectives from across the country who receive training in forensic genetic genealogy.

Othram DNA-Analyst Examines Human Bone From Crime Victim

David Mittelman, Othram’s founder, built the facility from the ground up to specialize in solving cold cases. The lab utilizes the world’s most powerful DNA sequencing technology.  David and Kristen met at the Baylor College of Medicine, where they studied gene therapy and DNA repair.  David earned a Ph.D. in molecular biophysics, and Kristen a Ph.D. in biochemistry and molecular biology.

The privately held company has received $18 million in funding from the Gigafund, a venture fund known for its large investments in companies like SpaceX.

Announcements that Othram helped crack another cold case have become weekly events.

Fort Worth Cold Case detectives solved the abduction, rape, and murder of 17-year-old Carla Walker after it had gone cold for nearly five decades.

Othram matched DNA from Walker’s clothing to a distant relative of the killer profiled on a genealogy database.

Cold case investigators Jeff Bennett and Leah Wagner identified 78-year-old Glen McCurley, who was listed among the original suspects.

McCurley pleaded guilty after two days of testimony in his capital murder trial in August 2021. 

Kristen Mittelman says it was one of the first time genetic genealogy evidence had been presented to a jury. “You see that people are getting away with murder. It’s more than that. I see that often people commit these horrible crimes and then live a very normal life in the middle of our society. Carla Walker’s murderer lived a mile away from the crime scene and had a wife and children. I’ve noticed this in these cases.”

Othram has received federal funding to help clear a backlog of cold cases.  A test to identify a perpetrator can cost upwards of seven thousand dollars and five thousand to identify the remains of a body.

Las Vegas philanthropist Justin Woo donated money for the testing in the Stephanie Isaacson case. 

It helped police connect the DNA of Darren Marchand to her murder. At the time, he was the married father of a two-year-old daughter with a son on the way.  Three years earlier, the then 20-year-old Las Vegas man had been arrested for the strangulation murder of a 24-year-old woman.

But the case was dismissed because of a lack of evidence. He died by suicide in 1995.

At the time of Isaacson’s murder, Marchand was awaiting sentencing for open and gross lewdness for exposing himself to five women. Two months after the murder, he was discharged from probation.

In the wake of the Carla Walker case, the Stephanie Isaacson case, and countless others, solved in part using Othram’s technology, Othram has leveraged crowdfunding and philanthropy to raise money and awareness for unsolved cases all over the United States. The initiative, DNASolves, aims to fund cases without traditional sources of support until one day all cases can be funded by federal and state budgets

Detective Jeff Bennett created the FWPD Cold Case Support Group, a nonprofit foundation to accept tax-deductible donations to help solve Fort Worth’s backlog of 1,000 cold cases.

Mittelman stresses that Othram’s forensic genetic genealogy findings only provide an investigative lead in cold cases. She praises investigators she has worked with for their dogged persistence. “These cases do not play out like a television police drama. The detectives have thought about this case every single day. It’s become part of who they are, part of their families, part of their lives, part of their dialect. The families of these victims have become part of their life.”

Robert Riggs is a Peabody Award-winning investigative reporter and creator of the True Crime Reporter® Podcast. He is the Executive Producer of Freed To  Kill, the chilling documentary about serial killer Kenneth McDuff featured on Fox Nation. You can contact Robert by email Fan@TrueCrimeReporter.com.


Filed Under: DNA

May 16, 2022 By Robert Riggs Leave a Comment

What Crimes Constitute Capital Murder In Texas?

  • murder of a peace officer or fireman who is acting in the lawful discharge of an official duty and who the person knows is a peace officer or fireman;
  • murder during the commission or attempted commission of kidnapping, burglary, robbery, aggravated sexual assault, arson, obstruction or retaliation, or terroristic threat;
  • murder for remuneration or promise of remuneration or employing another to commit murder for remuneration or promise of remuneration;
  • murder during escape or attempted escape from a penal institution;
  • murder, while incarcerated in a penal institution, of a correctional employee or with the intent to establish, maintain, or participate in a combination or in the profits of a combination;
  • murder while incarcerated in a penal institution for a conviction of murder or capital murder;
  • murder while incarcerated in a penal institution serving a life sentence or a 99-year sentence for a conviction of aggravated kidnapping, aggravated sexual assault, or aggravated robbery;
  • murder of more than one person during the same criminal transaction or during different criminal transactions but the murders are committed pursuant to the same scheme or course of conduct;
  • murder of an individual under 10 years of age, or older than 10 years of age but younger than 15 years of age; or
  • murder in retaliation for or on account of the service or status of the other person as a judge or justice of the supreme court, the court of criminal appeals, a court of appeals, a district court, a criminal district court, a constitutional county court, a statutory county court, a justice court, or a municipal court.

Filed Under: General

November 29, 2021 By Robert Riggs Leave a Comment

The Texas Ranger Files – Epic Stories Of Immeasurable Bravery

No man in the wrong can stand up against a fellow that’s in the right and keeps on a-comin’

–Texas Ranger Captain Bill McDonald

Texas Ranger Bob Prince 1976
Texas Rangers Frontier Battalion 1880
Modern Day Texas Rangers

From 1823 to the present day, a courageous group of men and women have been chosen to protect and serve the people of Texas. The Texas Rangers constitute the oldest state law enforcement organization in North America. 

The Ranger’s lore and legend endures because of its appealing heroic archetype of the self-reliant and brave law officer on horseback who faces challenges in Texas’ rugged frontier environment. 

Modern-day Texas Rangers may spend the morning on horseback and the evening on a laptop computer. They are responsible for conducting murder and government corruption investigations in rural Texas counties. Many of these cases while shocking rarely make the news outside of their local communities. 

Former federal prosecutor Bill Johnston and investigative reporter Robert Riggs established strong relationships with the legendary Texas Rangers during their careers.

L to R Bill Johnston, Ret’d Ranger Captain Bob Prince, Robert Riggs True Crime Reporter™ Podcast

The dynamic duo tap into a deep well of bizarre criminal cases in their episodes of True Crime Reporter™ The Texas Ranger Files. 

The Texas Rangers’ colorful history has been chronicled in numerous movies, television shows, radio programs, books, and now for the first time in this the True Crime Reporter™ podcast.

Real-life stories and fictional tales inspired by the Texas Rangers span the globe in entertainment.

Clayton Moore as The Lone Ranger

Children of the 1950s fondly remember the Saturday morning TV serial called the Lone Ranger about a masked former Texas Ranger who fought outlaws in the American Old West with his Indigenous American partner Tonto. 

Lonesome Dove, the 1989 American TV miniseries based on Larry McMurtry’s Pulitzer Prize-winning novel about two aging Texas Rangers who drive a herd of stolen cattle 2,500 miles from the Rio Grande to Montana captured the public imagination. 

It immortalized Charles Goodnight a legendary rancher and trailblazer who became known as the “father of the Texas Panhandle.” Goodnight served as a frontier scout and Texas Ranger in his youth.

Charles Goodnight. Courtesy of the University of North Texas.

Goodnight and his partner Oliver Loving established the Goodnight-Loving cattle trail which became one of the Southwest’s most heavily used cattle trails from South Texas to Colorado.

Goodnight and Loving’s friendship and adventures influenced McMurtry’s epic novel.

Chuck Norris in Walker Texas Ranger

In the 1990s Chuck Norris played the title role in the long-running TV series Walker, Texas Ranger. Norris battled criminals in Dallas and all around the great state of Texas. 

Jeff Bridges and Gil Birmingham as Texas Rangers in Hell Or High Water

More recently, Hollywood’s Hell or High Water depicted the fictional story of two Texas Rangers in pursuit of a pair of brothers who rob banks to save the family ranch from foreclosure.

Jeff Bridges who plays the part of one of the Rangers received an Oscar Nomination for Best Supporting Actor. Bridges credited the real-life renowned Texas Ranger Joaquin Jackson for helping him train for the role.

You can read more about Ranger Jackson in this issue of Texas Monthly magazine or read his book One Ranger Returns.

McLennan County Sheriff Parnell McNamara

Bridges also received guidance from former Deputy U.S. Marshal Parnell McNamara.

Hell or Highwater was written by Taylor Sheridan, McNamara’s cousin.

Taylor Sheridan at his Texas Horse Ranch credit Cowboys & Indians Magazine

Sheridan is the writer, director, and co-creator of the hit TV series Yellowstone.

U.S. Deputy Marshals Parnell & Mike McNamara

McNamara now the Sheriff of McLennan County and his late brother Mike are featured in the first season of the True Crime Reporter™ podcasts about the manhunt for serial killer Kenneth McDuff with Bill Johnston the cohost of True Crime Reporter™.

L-R Deputy U.S. Marshal Mike McNamara, Federal Prosecutor Bill Johnston, Deputy U.S. Marshal Parnell McNamara with Big Foot

A Ranger is an officer who is able to handle any given situation without definite instructions from his commanding officer or higher authority. This ability must be proven before a man becomes a Ranger.—Ranger Captain Bob Crowder

The birth of the Texas Rangers took place in 1823.  

Back then, Texas was a part of Mexico – which had just pulled away from Spain.  

The land mass of Texas was even larger than it is today.  The space amounted to more than a third of the United States.  

700 colonists called themselves “Texians” and although they were part of Mexico, they were pretty much on their own.  

The indigenous people of that day occupied most of the state, with the Comanches being the predominant and fiercest group of all.  The Comanches frequently raided the Texas settlements.  

Who could protect this vast landscape?  What was needed were some tough men who could “RANGE” around the Texas colonies- fleet on a horse, good with a gun. 

Portrait of Stephen F. Austin painted in 1833 by William Howard. Austin (Stephen F.) Papers, Dolph Briscoe Center for American History, The University of Texas at Austin.

 

Stephen F. Austin, known as the “Father of Texas”, organized two companies of frontiersmen as rangers for the common defense. 

The Texas “RANGERS” were born.  

In 1823 the Texas Rangers rode around the Texas colonies fending off attacks – chasing down the attackers.  More military-style defense, rather than law enforcement as we think of them today. 

When Texas declared its independence from Mexico, it was the Rangers who helped in the fight, being particularly good at scouting for the location of the Mexican Army.  Easy for them to do – they knew every pasture in Texas.

The provisional government of the Republic of Texas in 1835 authorized a “ranging company” of 25 Rangers, later increased to three companies of 56 men each.

Dawn at the Alamo Texas State Archives

At the Battle of the Alamo a year later, Rangers responded to Colonel William B. Travis’s appeal for help. They all died including the youngest who was in his teens at the time according to the Texas Ranger Hall of Fame and Museum.

Over time, the Rangers were organized into “Companies”  – each led by a Captain.  Each Captain was in charge of an area larger than most states in the Union.

Texas Rangers at the El Paso County Courthouse 1896

By the 1870s, the Rangers’ attention turned toward stopping cattle thieves raiding from Mexico, bank robbers, and western outlaw gangs like Jesse James and the James Brothers.  

Texas Ranger Frank Hamer on horseback

Famous Rangers came along, “Lone Wolf” Gonzaullus (pronounced Gonzales) who worked to keep the Texas oil fields safe, and Frank Hamer, who led the manhunt for the infamous “Bonnie and Clyde” gang in 1934. 

Bonnie Parker and Clyde Barrow were an American criminal couple during the time of the Great Depression. They became celebrities driving across the U.S., robbing banks, stores, and gas stations. 

Unlike other outlaws, Bonnie and Clyde were armed weapons developed during World War I, like Browning automatic rifles, and Thompson submachine guns. Small town police officers found themselves outgunned and outrun when the deadly duo roared into town in a Ford V8.

The head of the Texas prison system recruited, Frank Hamer, a legendary manhunter, to come out of retirement to track down Bonnie and Clyde. The gang had broken one of their accomplices out of prison killing two guards in the process. Hamer was appointed a special officer for the Texas Highway Patrol with the specific duty to capture the Barrow Gang.

Hamer hunted Bonnie and Clyde for more than 100 days. He and Ben Maney Gault, a veteran Texas Ranger tracked the gang to their hideout near Gibsland, Louisiana.

They staged a carefully orchestrated ambush riddling Bonnie and Clyde with a hail of deadly bullets. 

American historian Walter Prescott Webb described Hamer as one of the three most fearless men in Western history.

Earlier In 1908, Hamer served as the city Marshal of  Navasota, Texas where he single-handedly took on the Klu Klux Klan which had publicly hung innocent African American men accused of crimes. He returned to the Rangers a few years later. 

Even though the State was huge – the numbers of Rangers were small.  Only a very few could measure up to the standards which the Rangers had set, and only a few could handle the rigorous and lonely work.  

At the time of this episode in 2021, there are 172 women and men from all walks of life are posted to seven companies lettered “A” to “F” and an “H” company for headquarters.

The A to F districts are based in six geographic locations and H company is based in Austin, Texas, the state capital.

A Ranger captain supervises each company.  You will hear from one shortly.

Texas Ranger Captain Bob Prince With President George H.W. Bush

Because so much of Texas is rural, small sheriff’s offices were not equipped or trained to handle complex cases or most murder cases, or public corruption.  So, the Rangers became homicide specialists.  

Branch Davidian Compound Explodes April 19, 1993

True Crime Reporter’s cohost former federal prosecutor Bill Johnston called on the Texas Rangers to investigate one of the state’s most complicated crime scenes to date, The Branch Davidian Cult case.”  

On February 28th of 1993, seventy agents from the Alchohol Tobacco and Firearms agency known as ATF, attempted to serve search and arrest warrants at the Branch Davidian Compound called Mount Carmel Center located outside of Waco, Texas. 

They were met by a hail of gunfire, some from illegal machine guns.  During a two-hour gun battle, four federal ATF agents were killed and more than a dozen wounded.  Six Davidians were reportedly killed.

The cult was led by David Koresh who believed he was the spiritual heir of the biblical King David. Koresh espoused an apocalyptic vision based on his interpretation of Revelations.

Reporter Robert Riggs Outside WFAA-TV Channel 8 News Satellite Truck During the Branch Davidian Siege at Waco in 1993

Robert Riggs, the founder of True Crime Reporter™ covered the ensuing 51-day siege which ended in a fiery explosion and deaths of nearly 80 of Koresh’s followers including twenty-two children. Most of them had been huddled inside a massive ammunition bunker that blew up.  

Bill Johnston former federal prosecutor and cohost True Crime Reporter™ Podcast

Bill Johnston wrote the search warrant for the original raid and obtained lengthy jail sentences for some of the surviving cult members.

43 rangers worked at times on the investigation in assisting Johnston’s investigation.  

The Texas Rangers are structured like a paramilitary organization.

It consists of seven companies lettered “A” to “F” and an “H” company for headquarters.

The A to F districts are based in six geographic locations and H company is based in Austin, Texas, the state capital.

A Ranger captain supervises each company.  

The Texas Ranger Hall of Fame & Museum in Waco, Texas, is the state-designated official historical center of the famed law enforcement agency.

In this inaugural episode of True Crime Reporter™ Texas Ranger Files, Johnston and Riggs interviewed one of the most famous of the modern-day Texas Rangers, Retired Ranger Captain Bob Prince.

Randy Prince and Bob Prince – Father and Son Texas Ranger Captains

Captain Bob Prince and his son Randy are the only father and son in the history of the law enforcement organization to serve concurrently as Ranger Captains. 

Texas Ranger Sergeant Bob Prince 1985

Bob Prince tells a spellbinding story about how the Rangers rescued a 13-year old kidnap victim in a hail of gunfire in the first episode of True Crime Reporter™ Texas Ranger Files.  

Filed Under: General

December 21, 2020 By Robert Riggs Leave a Comment

Firearms Safety Video For First Time Gun Owners

This firearms safety video is a production of the SWAT Brothers Podcast.

Retired Lt. Robert Owens, a 40-year veteran of the Dallas Police Department discusses key safety measures for new gun buyers as well as experienced gun owners.

The retired officer and firearms instructor spent 20 years with Dallas SWAT and ran the department’s training range during his time with DPD.

He also ran Presidential Protection details by Dallas SWAT for President George W. Bush.

Owens teaches private lessons to high net worth individuals, celebrities, and professional athletes in North Texas through his firm OwenRiggs.com.

The year 2020 has been marked by record numbers of background checks which indicates tens of thousands of first-time gun buyers are arming themselves for self-protection in response to violent looting across the country.

Negligent discharges are already increasing due to a lack of training.

SWAT Brothers and OwenRiggs urge first-time gun buyers to get training from a professional or NRA certified instructor.

Filed Under: General

November 11, 2020 By Robert Riggs 17 Comments

Prisoners Stand To Receive Upwards of $2.6 Billion In Stimulus Payments

November 11, 2020 By Robert Riggs – Dallas, Texas

Millions of dollars in $1200 stimulus checks intended for economic relief for the COVID-19 pandemic are flowing into prisoners’ accounts inside prisons and jails across the country.

The stimulus payments could total as much as 2.76 billion dollars if all of the people incarcerated apply and qualify for the pandemic aid which is likely under the rules.

A Georgia prison warden not authorized to speak publically complained that the sudden windfall is fueling the supply of drugs and contraband cell phones inside prisons.  Flush with cash, inmates are paying their associates on the outside to use drones to fly contraband over the walls of prisons shut down by the coronavirus. 

A prison investigator said he was shocked to find that an inmate who had already served twenty years of a life sentence had received a $1200 stimulus check. The stimulus aid has caused a shift in the balance of power between prison gangs according to the investigator who was not permitted to speak on the record.

Prisoner advocacy groups across the country are assisting prisoners in filing claims.

For example, the Mississippi Center For Justice and the Southern Poverty Law Center in partnership with Black Lives Matter describes on the MCJ website that it mailed almost 18,000 CARES Act packets–each containing all relevant instructions and Form 1040 with a stamped return envelope to inmates.

A sample form provides step-by-step instructions on how to file for a $1200 stimulus check. 

The 2.3 million people incarcerated in U.S. jails and prisons are probably eligible to submit a “Non-Filer” claim to the IRS and will automatically receive $1200 stimulus checks.

Parnell McNamara the Sheriff of McLennan County, Texas says prisoners in his Waco jail are having their $1200 stimulus checks sent to family members.

“A lot of hardcore career criminals are receiving money intended for hard-working people. That they should receive one dime is a travesty,” said McNamara.

The IRS has sent thousands of forms to the Texas prison system for its 122-thousand inmates to claim $1200 stimulus checks under the CARES Act.  The prison system recently put up IRS posters instructing inmates on how to apply for economic relief for the COVID-19 pandemic.

This scene is playing out in state prisons and jails across the nation in the wake of a federal court order in October for the IRS to make the stimulus payments available to 2.3 million incarcerated prisoners. 

Less than ten stimulus checks have arrived at Texas prisons according to Jeremy Desel the Director of Communications for the Texas Department of Criminal Justice. 

Desel says it is the department’s policy to first confirm that the IRS checks are valid before depositing the money into an inmate’s commissary trust fund account. Texas inmates use the money to purchase snacks, soft drinks, ice cream, and toiletries not provided by the prison system. Inmates also have the option of having the checks sent to family members.

The 2-trillion dollar Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act or the CARES Act hastily passed by Congress on March 27 did not specifically ban payments to prisoners. The 883-page bill provided broad eligibility to get one-time payments for financial relief into people’s pockets as fast as possible. 

In May an internal auditor for the IRS discovered that the agency had automatically issued payments to prisoners. A federal report in June found that the government had paid $100 million in stimulus money to about 85,000 prisoners. The government demanded repayment and some federal prisons intercepted and returned stimulus checks.

A class-action lawsuit was filed in California on behalf of incarcerated individuals in local, state, and federal facilities that challenged the IRS actions.

A district court in San Francisco agreed, finding the IRS’s policy of withholding stimulus payments “arbitrary and capricious and not in accordance with the law.” 

On October 14, 2020, Chief Judge Phyllis J. Hamilton of the Northern District of California found the IRS’s policy of withholding stimulus payments “arbitrary and capricious and not in accordance with the law.”  Judge Hamilton ordered Treasury and the IRS to send the relief money. Read a copy of the Judge’s order.

Inmates who receive stimulus checks in error do not have to return those checks because Congress did not include a “clawback” provision in the CARES Act.

Filed Under: Prison

March 15, 2020 By Robert Riggs Leave a Comment

Inside The Mind Of A Psychopath – Kenneth Allen McDuff

The rotor blades of a low flying helicopter beat the Virginia sky with the distinctive thumping sound of Apocalypse Now. Gunfire cracks from all corners of the FBI’s sprawling Quantico Training Academy located south of the nation’s capital in Virginia.  

Agents of the elite Hostage Rescue Team clad in body armor, helmets, and goggles, step from the helicopter’s skids while precisely placing rounds into targets, as they practice rescuing a downed team member.

At another corner of the Academy on a mock Midwestern-style main street dubbed “Hogan’s Alley” agent trainees converge on a mock hotel where a violent fugitive is holed up.  Role-playing bad guys fire a volley of 9mm paintball rounds at the agent trainees from their handguns.

And at another point of the compass at the Academy, FBI agents assigned to the Hazardous Materials Response Unit teams don “moon suits” to practice the legal protocols of collecting forensic evidence from the site of a weapon of mass destruction attack. 

In sharp contrast to the frenetic training, a discreetly located Academy building houses the Behavioral Analysis Unit, which is commonly referred to as the “profilers”.  Mindhunter the Netflix TV series is a fictional account of how FBI Agent John E. Douglas helped found the unit to figure out how serial killers think.

In June 2006 I met Supervising Special Agent Mary Ellen O’Toole as she quietly and methodically unraveled clues that might help local detectives catch psychopaths who had committed monstrous crimes. 

O’Toole, who closely resembles the actor Ann Margaret, matched wits face-to-face with violent psychopaths throughout her career. O’Toole says a hallmark personality trait of the disorder is, “that lack of empathy for other people, that lack of concern for other people and what they are going through as a result of your actions. For a psychopath, they don’t have a sense of hurting of others, being concerned about what others think, they just don’t have it.”

O’Toole’s work often focused on psychopathic serial killers, child abductors, and sex offenders who have intertwined sex and violence, “that is a deadly combination. That’s a frightening combination,” she explains.

Serial Killer Kenneth Allen McDuff
Serial Killer Kenneth Allen McDuff

Indeed, serial killer Kenneth Allen McDuff, who murdered an estimated two dozen young women in Central Texas during the mid-1990’s, used a euphemism of “using them up” to describe his killings. 

The six-foot-four inch McDuff would take his victims to the brink of death and revive them to resume his sadistic sexual tortures.  McDuff’s name became synonymous with a revolving door prison system and triggered a major overhaul of the penal code in Texas.

Most state parole boards do not use the recognized tests to determine if an inmate is a psychopath before they vote to release an offender.  O’Toole says it’s only a matter of time until a psychopath commits a new crime.

 “It’s a very short period of time before he or she will re-offend and re-offend in a violent way. Some of the current research indicates that psychopathic sex offenders who undergo prison treatment programs are actually worse when they are released,” she says.  

Psychopaths can learn how to perfect their crimes from prison therapy programs says O’Toole. “Psychopathy is a personality disorder. It does not lend itself to treatment or to rehabilitation. So if you think you can help someone become a non-psychopath that’s very naive.”

Air Force Cadet David Graham and his fiancée Naval Midshipman Diane Zamora appear to have been a marriage of psychopaths. The Texas couple murdered a former high school classmate in a twisted plot for Graham to prove his love for Zamora.  Both are now serving life sentences in the Texas prison system for capital murder. 

In a display typical of the cold-hearted grandiosity of psychopaths, Graham believes that after taking college courses in prison that he could be a poster boy for rehabilitation, “I think if I got out today I would be the ultimate example of respect of life. I would probably be the best way to learn why to cherish life and why not to take a life.”

There are an estimated two million psychopaths in North America.  It’s crucial that people recognized the traits of a psychopath who may be very close to them in personal and work relationships.  Some of the traits resemble the personalities of celebrities and politicians, but O’Toole stresses that it requires an expert analysis.

Besides a lack of conscience, O’Toole says a psychopath is also manipulative, self-centered, extremely narcissistic, glib, charming, and impulsive. She also notes that they are unable to bond in relationships, live life on the edge, blame others for their mistakes; and lead a parasitic life style, “whether they are a criminal, or they are your boss, or whatever aspect, or they are your husband, they can really wreck havoc in people’s lives.” 

Most people mistakenly believe that psychopaths are essentially killers or convicts. O’Toole warns that there are white collar psychopaths who may head corporations or governments, “they can go in and create a great deal of confusion, tumultuousness, and have no regard if the company or the country implodes on itself because their primary interest is on themselves.”

O’Toole says that if you are worried that you may be a psychopath, then you are not. During a prison interview, O’Toole says an inmate gave a very good definition of what a psychopath is, and said he felt being one was a good thing.

 “People who have these traits view these traits as allowing them to do special things, Allowing them to live on the edge. Allowing them to get away with things. Because a conscience really limits you.  You are constrained because of your emotions. A psychopath does not have those kinds of constraints.”

Filed Under: Serial Killer

March 19, 2014 By Robert Riggs Leave a Comment

Operation Noble Eagle Responds To September 11 Terrorist Attacks

ROBERT RIGGS REPORTS FROM OVER NEW YORK CITY

The crisp blue sky over New York City resembled the day that dawned on September 11, 2001 three years earlier.

Ground zero could be clearly seen from the cockpit of F-15 fighters circling above Manhattan Island at twenty-three thousand feet.

Robert Riggs is the first reporter allowed to fly on post 9-11 air defense patrol in USAF F-15 fighter

Robert Riggs is the first reporter allowed to fly on post 9-11 air defense patrol in USAF F-15 fighter

That was my vantage point from the back seat of an F-15 of the 71st Fighter Squadron known as the “Ironmen”.

The squadron’s aircraft protected the airspace over New York City as President George W. Bush addressed the United Nations about Iraq on September 21, 2004.

Fighters, wings bristling with live weapons, sharply banked and dived through congested airways to intercept suspicious aircraft.

F-15 fighters armed with live missiles on Homeland Security Patrol

F-15 fighters armed with live missiles on Homeland Security Patrol

I strained against “G” forces and my stomach often felt like it was in my throat.

The routine patrol could quickly turn into an adrenaline rush.

In a split second, a pilot could be ordered to shoot a radar guided AIM-120 Advanced Medium-Range Air-to-Air Missile, or a heat seeking AIM-9M Sidewinder missile, or a burst of 20-millimeter machine gun fire into a hijacked civilian aircraft.

Videographer Manuel Villela and I were the first TV journalists given wide access to the post 9-11 air defense mission called Operation Noble Eagle.

The patrol marked the last line of defense if terrorist hijackers attempted another round of suicide attacks.

KC-135 Tanker from 128th Refueling Wing of the Wisconsin Air National Guard gases up F-15 protecting skies over New York City

KC-135 Tanker from 128th Refueling Wing of the Wisconsin Air National Guard gases up one of many F-15 fighters protecting the airspace over New York City

 

In the wake of 9-11, fighter pilots must now think about the unthinkable.

“It is true that this is the force of last resort. This is something that we have found totally unthinkable in the past but we think about it and think about it in detail today”, says General Hal Hornburg the Commander of Air Combat Command.

From his headquarters at Langley Air Force Base in the Virginia Tidewater area, Hornburg says pilots will not hesitate to follow orders to use lethal force, “I wouldn’t want it to be me, I wouldn’t want it to be someone that worked for me, but as we in the military that sign up for this, and support and defend the Constitution, there’s no doubt in my mind that training would take over and it would happen.”

Pilots and fighters, mostly from Air National Guard squadrons, stand alert at bases across the Continental United States, Alaska, and Canada ready scrambled after an unidentified aircraft.

Active duty Air Force squadrons routinely fly combat air patrols over high profile events and presidential appearances.

We flew with thirty-three year old Major Brian Gienapp and his wingman twenty-five year old Lt. James Morgan of the 71st Fighter Squadron.

L-R Reporter Robert Riggs and USAF F-15 pilot Major Brian Gienapp following 9-11 air defense patrol in November 2004

L-R Reporter Robert Riggs and USAF F-15 pilot Major Brian Gienapp following 9-11 air defense patrol in September 2004

Gienapp, an Air Force Academy graduate and veteran of one hundred combat hours over Iraq, places his confidence in the secret rules of engagement that govern the use of deadly force against a civilian aircraft.

“It’s definitely an enormous thought to grasp and it’s definitely something we have all thought of and contemplated. The bottom line is that these scenarios have been well thought out and there are definitely safeguards to make sure an accident would never happen.”

It is nerve wracking flying armed fighters in the midst of crowded civilian air traffic. The patrols last as long as six hours and require air-to-air refueling.

USAF Lt. James "Tracer" Morgan taps into a flying gas station during a Homeland Security Mission to protect the President in September 2004

USAF Lt. James “Tracer” Morgan taps into a flying gas station during a Homeland Security Mission to protect the President in September 2004

Lt. Morgan, call sign “Tracer”, gently eased his fighter behind a KC-135 tanker from the 128th Refueling Wing of the Wisconsin Air National Guard while circling over New York City.

Pulling alongside the tanker’s wingtip made this reporter feel like a fish bobbing on an invisible ocean next to a whale.

Our television lens could not capture the disorienting sensation of moving in three dimensions.

Cameraman Manuel Villeala shoots video of air-to-air refueling from backseat of an F-15 fighter

Cameraman Manuel Villeala shoots video of air-to-air refueling from backseat of an F-15 fighter

A boom sticking out of the tanker’s tail floated past Morgan’s canopy and scored a direct bull’s eye into the fuel receptacle on the fighter’s port side wing.

Morgan made it look easy but admitted that air-to-air refueling under the best of conditions still makes him nervous. Gienapp chuckled, “wait until you try it in total darkness during a combat mission.”

Morgan, a mechanical engineering graduate of Duke University, says the thought is always in the back of his mind during these missions that something could happen in the next five minutes that could trigger a deadly intercept, “hopefully there’s no problem and we are just ready. It might be a very benign mission that isn’t incredibly challenging. But I think you have to be ready for the challenge at any moment because it’s a much graver situation if we do have to perform.”

Morgan says he and his fellow pilots in the 71st Fighter Squadron trust that the chain of command above them will make the right decision, “we are confident in that we will, if we are given the order, it’s the right order and for the right reason we will do it. For me personally my faith in God goes well above that. To know he would protect me to do the right thing.”

Exclusive Look Inside Tyndall Air Force Base 1st Air Force Command Post

The critical decision making process starts inside the 1st Air Force command post at Tyndall Air Force Base in the Florida Panhandle.

Combined Air Operations Center for Southeastern Air Defense Sector at Tyndall AFB in Florida tracks thousands of aircraft

Combined Air Operations Center for Southeastern Air Defense Sector at Tyndall AFB in Florida tracks thousands of aircraft

It monitors six thousand flights at any given time over the United States inside a facility called the Combined Air Operations Center The banks of radar scopes and computer screens resemble the war room in the movie “War Games”.

Hundreds of green blips of light representing aircraft look like a swarm of fire flies on the radar scopes. Battle commanders and radar technicians watch, track, and identify suspicious aircraft around the clock everyday.

 

Thousands of blips represent aircraft. The USAF command post must sort out friend from possible foe.

Thousands of blips represent aircraft. The USAF command post must sort out friend from possible foe.

Before 2001, the Air Force only looked for threats coming from outside U.S. borders. The need for the air defense appeared to vanish with the fall of the Soviet Union and it was being phased out.

On 9-11 a surreal scene unfolded inside. A simulated exercise was underway when the World Trade Center Towers were hit. Since then a new homeland air defense mission has been engaged in an air war over America.

Major General Craig McKinley the Commander of 1st Air Force fields six serious warnings a day at all hours. McKinley is responsible for alerting the higher chain of command up to the Secretary of Defense and President who may be called upon to make the ultimate decision.

L. to R. Reporter Robert Riggs & Major General Craig McKinley, Commander of 1st Air Force, in October 2004

L. to R. Reporter Robert Riggs & Major General Craig McKinley, Commander of 1st Air Force, in October 2004

McKinley, a 1974 graduate of the ROTC program at Southern Methodist University in Dallas, says that the command position has proved so stressful that it has been cut from a four year tour to two years, “sometimes we have minutes or hours to deal with a situation and sometimes we have seconds to deal with it.”

McKinley receives his initial warning from command posts at air defense sectors. The 48 contiguous states are divided into three sectors: Western at McChord AFB, Washington; Northeastern at Rome, New York; and Southeastern which is located in the same facility with McKinley’s command post at Tyndall AFB, Florida.

I was the first journalist ever allowed inside the Combined Air Operations Center and the Southeastern Air Defense Sector which deals with more unknown targets than any other sector in the nation.

We found Major Sharon Nehrings of the Florida Air National Guard focused on a 30 mile ring of restricted airspace around Tampa.

The ring on the radar screen followed President George W. Bush overhead as his campaign rallies moved up the Florida Gulf Coast in late October of 2004.

It’s called a POTUS mission, short for President of the United States.

Symbols of two fighters and a refueling tanker crisscrossed inside the circle.

Nehrings is the mission crew commander on duty during our visit to the Southeaster Air Defense Sector.

A mission filled with hours of boredom and minutes of sheer terror.

The fourteen year veteran is responsible for launching an intercept against a suspicious aircraft, “it’s very intense because you are dealing with people’s lives. It can be hours of boredom and then minutes of sheer terror.”

An unidentified aircraft suddenly interrupts our interview. It flies into the President’s restricted airspace. Nehrings orders air controllers sitting to her right to direct fighters to the target.

It is a hair raising moment as seconds tick away. There’s little time to react if it’s a jetliner moving at eight miles a minute.

As the intercept unfolds, FAA liaison Ron Davidson of Fort Worth keeps an open line of communication to civilian air traffic controllers. They can’t raise the pilot by radio.

The Secret Service also receives a warning in case it needs to evacuate the President.

FAA Liaison Ron Davidson keeps communications open between civilian air traffic controllers and USAF interceptors.

FAA Liaison Ron Davidson keeps communications open between civilian air traffic controllers and USAF interceptors.

The order to intercept triggers a chain reaction of response. General McKinley and his staff begin looking at the national air picture for any hint of air trouble elsewhere that might hint of a coordinated attack.

The calculus includes a quick determination if the target aircraft is headed toward buildings or critical infrastructure.

Commanders must weigh the risk of shooting down an aircraft versus the collateral damage that could be caused on the ground.

F-15 from 71st Fighter Squadron "Ironmen" flies Homeland Security Mission

F-15 from 71st Fighter Squadron “Ironmen” flies Homeland Security Mission

When fighter pilots make visual contact with an unresponsive target aircraft, they use hand signals, rock their wings, or in a final warning drop flares to tell its pilot to turn away. The fighter pilots use secret codes to authenticate any order to open fire.

The air space violation we witnessed turned out to be the careless pilot of small single engine plane. Fighters escorted it away from the President’s campaign rally, but the roar of came close enough to grab the attention of the crowd.

Military officials complain that such violations occur much too often and that there are no severe FAA penalties for offenders.

More than thirty eight thousand Noble Eagle Missions had been flown without incident by October of 2004.

The hundreds of young men and women working for McKinley have coolly handled situations in which airline pilots have accidentally sent a coded hijacking signal. And two actual hijackings out of Cuba have been safely diverted by fighters to Key West, Florida.

Senior Airman Tanish Jordan describes the loading of air-to-air missiles on F-15 fighters

Senior Airman Tanish Jordan describes the loading of air-to-air missiles on F-15 fighters

It is an orchestrated effort supported by thousands of airmen. Everyone from Airman First Class Nathaniel Robinson of Barnwell, South Carolina, who makes sure that pilots’ oxygen masks and equipment are in working order to Senior Airmen Tanish Jordan of Waycross, Georgia, who loads missiles.

Air Force General Pledges A 9/11 Will Not Happen Again

The sight of armed aircraft and pilots ready to bolt for their cockpits on Air Force flight lines around the country underscores the seriousness of how the Global War on Terrorism is also being fought over America.

Major General McKinley says the Air Force repeatedly practices and knows what it takes to give an aircraft a chance to comply with instructions but will not hesitate to use force, “we wait until the last possible minute. But we are not going to have a recurrence of September 11, 2001. The American public won’t stand for it and the United States military is on guard to protect American citizens.”

Filed Under: Terrorism

October 24, 2012 By Robert Riggs 3 Comments

How Did The Ice Pick Murderer Get Keys To His Victim’s Apartment

 

Convicted Ice Pick Killer Bobby Lee Hines

Convicted killer Bobby Lee Hines was executed on October 24, 2012 for strangling and repeatedly stabbing a suburban Dallas woman at her apartment 21 years ago.

 

26 YEAR OLD MICHELLE WENDY HAUPT WAS STABBED AND STRANGLED BY A CONVICTED FELON WHO ENTERED HER APARTMENT WITH A STOLEN PASS KEY.

HER MURDER FORCED TEXAS LANDLORDS TO BEEF UP SECURITY TO COMPLY WITH THE NATION’S FIRST KEYLESS DEAD BOLT LAW.

ON OCTOBER 19TH OF 1991, THE ASSISTANT MANAGER OF HAUPT’S APARTMENT COMPLEX WHO HAD FIVE BURGLARY CONVICTIONS BEFORE BEING HIRED GAVE A PASS KEY TO HIS BROTHER, BOBBY LEE HINES.

IN THE EARLY HOURS OF THE FOLLOWING SUNDAY MORNING, HAUPT’S NEIGHBORS HEARD A WOMAN SCREAMING FOR 15-MINUTES AND WHAT SOUNDED LIKE A BOWLING BALL BEING DROPPED ONTO THE FLOOR 20-TIMES.

HINES WHO WAS THEN 19-YEARS OLD USED THE PASS KEY TO SURPRISE HAUPT IN HER APARTMENT.  HINES STABBED HAUPT 18-TIMES WITH AN ICE PICK BEFORE STRANGLING HER WITH A SPEAKER CORD.

WHEN POLICE APPREHENDED HINES THEY FOUND HAUPT’S GOLD SAND-DOLLAR NECKLACE AMONG HIS POSSESSIONS.

HINES WAS CONVICTED OF CAPITAL MURDER AND EXECUTED ON OCTOBER 24, 2012. 

BEFORE HIS LETHAL INJECTION, HINES’ FINAL WORDS WERE: “I KNOW I TOOK SOMEBODY SPECIAL FROM Y’ALL. I KNOW IT WASN’T RIGHT; IT WAS WRONG. I WISH I COULD GIVE IT BACK, BUT I KNOW I CAN’T. I WISH THERE WAS SOMETHING I COULD DO. I DON’T BELIEVE TAKING MY LIFE WILL SOLVE ANYTHING. I BELIEVE BEING LOCKED UP FOR THE REST OF MY LIFE, HAVING TO THINK ABOUT WHAT I DID, THAT WOULD BE MORE OF A PUNISHMENT. TO DO THIS IS SETTING ME FREE.”

TWO COMPANIES THAT WERE THEN CO OWNED BY DALLAS REAL ESTATE INVESTOR CRAIG HALL WHICH MANAGED THE COMPLEX SETTLED A WRONGFUL DEATH SUIT BY HAUPT’S FAMILY FOR MORE THAN FIVE MILLION DOLLARS.

STOLEN PASS KEYS HELPED CRIMINALS OPEN THE DOOR ON AN ESTIMATED 150 RAPE VICTIMS IN 1993 BEFORE THE A LEGAL CRACKDOWN.

THE CASE PROMPTED TEXAS LAWMAKERS TO PASS THE KEYLESS DEAD BOLT LAW ON DECEMBER 12, 1994.

THE PROVISIONS OF THE TEXAS’ KEYLESS DEAD BOLT LAW ARE

  • THE TENANT CAN INSTALL THE LOCK AND DEDUCT IT’S COST FROM THE MONTHLY RENT.
  • OR THE TENANT CAN SUE THE LANDLORD INTO COMPLYING.
  • OR THE TENANT CAN SUE THE LANDLORD FOR UP TO 500 DOLLARS IN DAMAGES.

AT TIME OF THE LAW’S PASSAGE, DOUG LIEBMAN, HAUPT’S STEPBROTHER, SAID “I BELIEVE THAT IF IT HELPS SOMEONE ELSE OR PROTECTS YOUNG WOMEN LIVING ALONE FROM HERE ON OUT CERTAINLY THERE’S SOMETHING TO FEEL GOOD ABOUT.”

THE LAW REQUIRES ALL RENTAL PROPERTIES TO PUT KEYLESS DEAD BOLTS ON EXTERIOR DOORS THAT ONLY THE TENANT CAN UNLOCK FROM INSIDE.

THE LOCK MUST BE PLACED BETWEEN THREE AND FOUR FEET ABOVE THE FLOOR.

IN ADDITION THE LAW REQUIRES A KEY LOCKING DOOR KNOB OR KEYED DEADBOLT AS WELL AS PEEPHOLES AND EXTRA SECURITY ON SLIDING GLASS DOORS.

THE LAW MAKES EXCEPTIONS FOR ELDERLY RESIDENTS THAT NEED TO BE CHECKED ON BY LANDLORDS.

CRIME VICTIMS GROUPS SAY THE LAW SHOULD ALSO HAVE REQUIRED LANDLORDS TO INSTALL STURDIER KICK PROOF DOORS.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Filed Under: Death Row, Murder

JOIN OUR TRUE CRIME COMMUNITY

Get notified about new episodes and exclusive access to free information.

Search

Recent Blog Post

Othram DNA Lab In Texas Helps Solve 29-Year-Old Murder Case

How Forensic Genetic Genealogy Found Distant Relative Of Killer 14-year Stephanie Anne Isaacson left her father’s apartment in North Las Vegas early on the morning of June 1, 1989. She walked … Continue Reading

Recent Episodes

Inside the Minds of Death Row Inmates: A Terrifying Journey Into Evil

China Kills Hundreds With Deadly Fentanyl – It Ought To Be A Crime

Women Who Kill: This Bank Robber Viciously Shot Her Victim In The Back

Search

Copyright © 2023 True Crime Reporter

Sitemap · Privacy Policy · Terms & Conditions · Disclaimer · Cookies Policy

Manage Cookie Consent
We use cookies to optimize our website and our service.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage vendors Read more about these purposes
Preferences
{title} {title} {title}