Robert Riggs
Texas found itself under siege by violent criminals set free by the state parole board in the 1980s and 1990s.
In the first episode on True Crime Reporter, we learned the board freed 85 notorious former death-row inmates to relieve prison overcrowding.
Texas politicians talked tough on crime, but they did not build new prisons.
The prison system teetered on the brink of a shutdown. A federal judge threatened to take it over because of overcrowded conditions.
So, to avoid political embarrassment, the parole board threw open the floodgates.
They released 56,000 ex-cons alone in 1989.
Among them was the Broomstick Killer. He was supposed to die in the electric chair.
Three days after he walked out of prison on parole, womenâs bodies started showing up, and others started disappearing.
His killing streak ran two and a half years. Then U.S. marshals picked up the trail of Kenneth McDuff.
A modern-day Jack the Ripper snatched a young woman out of a Waco convenience store in the middle of the night.
Twenty-two-year-old Melissa Northrup, a pregnant mother of two children, vanished during her shift on a lonely stretch of Interstate 35.
A widespread search for the petite clerk turned up an abandoned, two-door, tan 1985 Thunderbird nearby.
The car belonged to paroled triple killer Kenneth Allen McDuff.
When an FBI agent mentioned McDuffâs name in passing, Deputy U.S. Marshal Parnell McNamara stopped dead in his tracks.
Parnell McNamara
The first time we really started to get on McDuffâs trail was when Melissa Northrup disappeared from the Quick-Pak where she was working on South I-35. I believe it was March 1, 1992, and she just vanished, so we didnât know who had gotten her. About a week later, we got a helicopter that belonged to the sheriffâs office here. My brother and I were in the helicopter, along with a couple of other deputy sheriffs, and we were flying all around, just trying to find some kind of clue.
Then, on about the fifth or sixth day, Mike, my brother, who was also a deputy U.S. marshal, and Bill Johnston, the U.S. attorney here, were walking down the sidewalk going to lunch. We were approached by an FBI agent stationed here in Waco, Freddie Vela. He said, âHey, let me ask you something. Does the name Kenneth McDuff mean anything to you?â
I said, âOh my gosh, yes, absolutelyâa triple murderer. Why are you asking me this?â
He said, âWell, his car has just shown up in the parking lot of the new road in on South I-35, right next to the Quick-Pak.â
Robert Riggs
Where Melissa Northrup hadâ
Parnell McNamara
âwhere Melissa Northrup had disappeared the same day. I said, âYou donât have to be Sherlock Holmes or Dick Tracy to solve this case. Like, you have a dead girl in the alley, and youâve got Jack the Ripper down at the end of the alley with a knife in his hand? Thatâs a pretty good place to start.â
At that point, all three of us said, âMy gosh, McDuff is the one doing all this,â because there were several girls who were missing.
Robert Riggs
The marshals knew 46-year-old Kenneth Allen McDuff as the Broomstick Killer.
In the last episode, I explained how McDuff dodged his sentence to die in the electric chair.
The parole board set McDuff and 84 other convicted capital murderers free to relieve prison overcrowding in Texas.
Back in August 1966, McDuff and an accomplice named Roy Dale Green abducted and murdered three teenagers in Fort Worth.
Author Gary Lavergne says McDuffâs accomplices provided him with an audience for his violent performances.
Gary Lavergne
Both of these unfortunateâand Iâve gotten into trouble for saying this, because youâre not supposed to use the word âstupidââbut both of those men suffered from what I call in my book âheartbreaking stupidity.â And Iâve gotten into trouble for even saying that. But I couldnât kid myself anymore. Thatâs what was going on. And McDuff understood that. I mean, itâs not like McDuff picked out a high school graduate to bring along. He wanted to impress people with his brutality, and anyone with an ounce of intelligence or education would not have been impressed.
Robert Riggs
Armed with a .38-caliber revolver, McDuff surprised Robert Brand and his cousin Marcus Dunnam while they were talking with Edna Sullivan, a popular high school junior.
McDuff ordered the teenage boys at gunpoint into the trunk of their car.
The boys begged for their lives.
McDuff shot Robert Brand in the ear and forehead.
Mark Dunnam tried to shield himself. McDuff shot him through the arm, then grabbed the boy by the hair, put the muzzle of his pistol against Markâs head, and coolly squeezed off a round.
Next, McDuff raped the young woman several times, sexually assaulted her with a jagged broomstick, then choked her to death with it. That is how McDuff got his moniker, âthe Broomstick Killer.â
McDuff was no stranger to crime. The 19-year-old had already been to prison for thirteen counts of burglary and theft.
McDuff had been out of prison on parole for eight months when he murdered the three teenagers.
Parnell McNamara, now the sheriff of McLennan County, and Larry Pamplin, the former sheriff of Falls County, knew McDuff better than anyone in law enforcement.
We sat down together to talk about the Broomstick Killer.
Robert Riggs
What was your history? Your father had a history in this. Tell us about your father, who was originally involved in capturing him.
Parnell McNamara
My father was a deputy U.S. marshal here in Waco from 1942 up to 1978. He worked very closely with Sheriff Brady Pamplin of Falls County, our neighboring county. In fact, for probably the first 10 to 12 years of my dadâs career with the U.S. Marshals, all of the federal prisoners were kept in the Falls County jail because the McLennan County jail was not federally approved. As a young boyâIâm talking about very young, four or five years oldâI would ride with my father to Marlin when he transported prisoners.
Thatâs where I met Larry and Brady Miles Pamplin when they were very young, about my same age. Weâd play together when we went down there. My father and Brady worked very closely together, and there was a respect between those two tough, tough lawmenâa sheriff and a U.S. marshalâthat was just incredible. It was unbelievable.
I first heard of McDuff in 1966, when he killed those three teenagers in Everman, by Fort Worth. I can remember being with my father because, starting in January 1963, my father got permission from the Justice Department to use my brother and me as federal guards. We went with my dad to make arrests, transport prisoners to and from court, and take them to Leavenworth Penitentiary, El Reno, and all over the place.
This happened in 1966, when I was a sophomore at Baylor. My dad and I were in Marlin, transporting a prisoner down there. I remember Sheriff Pamplin talking to my father about this brutal murder that had just happened. This guy named McDuffâyou know, once you hear that name associated with a murder, you donât forget McDuff.
Robert Riggs
And he already had a reputation.
Parnell McNamara
He had a reputation as a low-life thug and a punk. I remember Brady Pamplinâs hand shaking and his voice trembling as he told my father how McDuff had killed those three teenagers, especially the little girl, and put a broomstick across her throat after he had used it on her. He had brutally sexually assaulted her and left her on her back on a gravel road.
I remember the sheriff shaking and saying, âTP, he broke her neck just like you would kill a possum.â
I remember how sick I was. My fatherâs reactionâI know either one of those men would have killed McDuff at the drop of a hat, and so would I. I was a guard. I didnât have a badge or credentials, but I had a gun. To hear something like that happen in such a brutal way just made me sick, and I never forgot it.
Robert Riggs
Then he shows up, and thereâs a gunfight or a standoff.
Parnell McNamara
Exactly. The night after the brutal murders, McDuff comes back home. The next night, he has a date with a young girl who lives in Bremond.
Robert Riggs
Seems unbelievable.
Parnell McNamara
Unbelievable.
Robert Riggs
Triple murder, and heâs out on a date.
Parnell McNamara
Yeah, and heâs out on his date like nothing ever happened. At that point, Sheriff Pamplin had been made aware that a cohort named Roy Dale Green had been with McDuff when those murders happened the day before.
As I remember it, Green and another individual, and a young girl that the other guy had a date with, were in a car. They heard over the radio that this young girl and these two young boys had been murdered at Fort Worth. Apparently, Roy Dale Green got very upset and may have started crying. The fellow who was with him slapped him to get him to come to his senses and said, âWhat are you talking about?â
He broke down and said, âI was with Kenneth McDuff when he killed those kids.â
They went straight to the Falls County Sheriffâs Office, to Sheriff Pamplin. Then Sheriff Pamplin got in touch with Sonny Eliot, sheriff for Robertson County, where Bremond is. They proceeded along with Sheriff Pamplinâs son, Larry Pamplin, who happened to be in town at that time. He was a college student in 1966, like I was.
Robert Riggs
Who is here with us today.
Parnell McNamara
He is here with us today. He sure is. He can fill in the details of that dayâor that nightâbetter than I can.
Larry Pamplin
My name is Larry Pamplin.
Robert Riggs
Larry Pamplin vividly remembers a running gun battle with Kenneth McDuff.
They found McDuff driving around with his date in the car.
Pamplinâs father, the sheriff of Falls County, emptied his shotgun into the carâs radiator so he would not hit the young woman inside.
The engine overheated, and McDuff bailed out.
He jumped into a pickup truck driven by his dateâs brother. The chase resumed.
Larry Pamplin
I was able to get right up beside them. My dad reloaded and jacked another one in the 12-gauge, and he was fixing to take care of business. At that point, the brother slammed on the brakes. The truck slid to a stop, the door flew open, and McDuff was on the passenger side. He just flew out onto the pavement, face down.
Robert Riggs
The Pamplins captured McDuff.
McDuff and his accomplice were placed in solitary confinement at the Tarrant County Jail because inmates, outraged by the brutality of the murders, threatened to kill the pair.
In November 1966, the ex-con, now 20 years old, went on trial for capital murder.
Prosecutors described McDuff as a cold-blooded, sexually deranged killer.
Spectators packed the Fort Worth courtroom.
His accomplice, 18-year-old Roy Dale Green, a skinny, emaciated high school dropout, testified against McDuff for five hours.
Green described how McDuff pressed a jagged broomstick across the 16-year-old womanâs throat and choked her to death.
Green admitted that he held down her legs to stop her from kicking. They threw her body into a clump of scrub brush.
In a written statement, Green said McDuff told him afterward that he had raped and killed before.
McDuff took the stand in an attempt to blame his accomplice.
McDuff claimed Green dropped him off at a burned-out shopping center, where he spent the night. Green, he said, left to find a girl.
His mother, Addie, and his sisters watched his testimony from the front row of the courtroom.
The jury of nine men and three women deliberated for four hours. They sentenced McDuff to die in the electric chair.
The convicted triple killer spent six years on death row.
In 1972, the U.S. Supreme Court struck down the death penalty as unconstitutional.
McDuffâs death sentence, along with those of 129 other capital murderers in Texas, was commuted to life.
Then the parole board secretly released 85 former death-row inmates to relieve prison overcrowding.
In 1989, McDuff walked out of prison after receiving parole under very suspicious circumstances.
Thatâs when Pamplin picked up the phone to warn Parnell McNamara and made an ominous prediction.
Larry Pamplin
I told Parnell, âYouâre not going to believe this. This is just crazy. But I just received the information that Kenneth Allen McDuff has been released from TDC. Mark my wordâI donât know if itâll be three days, three weeks, or three months, but I promise you bodies are fixing to start showing up.â And I think it was three days later.
Robert Riggs
McDuffâs release alarmed McNamara. He found out the ex-con was enrolled in a trade school class there in Waco.
Parnell McNamara
When all this was going on, Sheriff Pamplin called me and told me they had paroled McDuff, of all people. We were just in a state of disbelief. I immediately went to the Texas State Technical College Police Department and told them, âYouâve got a triple murderer going to school here.â
Then the sheriff told me he found out McDuff was attending college on a state grant. So we were paying for this scumbag piece of trash to go to school, you know. That was more salt in the wound.
Robert Riggs
But he really wasnât going to school. We later found he was cutting claâ
Parnell McNamara
No, he wouldnât go inâ
Robert Riggs
Never going to class.
Parnell McNamara
He was cutting class, and he was killing people as we were looking at him. We were looking at him very hard, but really didnât have anything to go on. There were girls who were disappearing, prostitutes. We were concerned about them because, as weâve said before, every prostitute was at some point someoneâs little girl. They werenât always a prostitute, and they didnât deserve to die like this.
Robert Riggs
True to Sheriff Pamplinâs prediction, the body of Sarafia Parker turned up near the trade school three days after McDuff got out of prison.
The petite woman, a sex worker, had been raped, beaten, and strangled to death.
Parker was last seen alive with McDuff in his pickup the day before her body was discovered.
It was the same day McDuff first reported to his parole officer after his release from prison on parole.
Parnell McNamara
He was so brutal and so heartless and soulless that, the more we got into the investigation, and we knew what he had done to those young kids in 1966, his brutality was just over the top. He thoroughly enjoyed inflicting pain, misery, and terror on his victims.
Robert Riggs
Next on True Crime Reporter: the marshals and U.S. Attorney Bill Johnston form a three-man posse to hunt down Kenneth Allen McDuff.
Bill Johnston
We want him off the street because Mike and Parnell convinced me that if McDuff was out, he was killing. I didnât understand the nature of a serial killer like he was. I was learning. But they convinced me he was going to be abducting and killing girls. He is a horrible predator.
Robert Riggs
To follow True Crime Reporter, text TRUE CRIME to 33777. Once again, text TRUE CRIME to 33777.