“Freed To Kill” A Texas Posse Gets On The Trail Of Serial Killer Kenneth McDuff Episode 3 – Season 1

By Robert Riggs

What You Will Learn

A pair of Deputy U.S. Marshals and a young, aggressive federal prosecutor suspects that triple killer and former death row inmate Kenneth McDuff is behind the abduction of a convenience store clerk in Waco, Texas. 

When no other law enforcement organizations are willing to pursue a hot lead, the trio organizes an old-style Texas posse.

The U.S. Marshals Service’s top fugitive hunters join the posse.

They recruit an Irish cop from New York City who works undercover in the Texas prison system.

You can follow their trail as they track McDuff through a filthy underworld of ex-cons with a vengeance

What You Will Learn

  • How U.S. Attorney Bill Johnston secured a federal arrest warrant using evidence tied to a single tab of LSD.
  • Why U.S. Marshals pursued McDuff under that warrant even though they had no murder warrant.
  • How the McNamaras and their posse searched Central Texas’s criminal underworld for McDuff.
  • How undercover investigator John Moriarty used his knowledge of prison networks to help the manhunt.

Stay One Step Ahead of Danger

withStories to Keep You Safe

Recognize the warning signs before you become a victim.

Get Robert Riggs’ newsletter for reporting on violent crime, AI threats, and hidden dangers—plus practical steps to help protect yourself and your family.

Books by Robert Riggs

Texas Crime Stories: Blood & Betrayal, by Robert Riggs

Latest publication

Texas Crime Stories

Blood & Betrayal

Riding Herd on the Lawless ¡ Vol. 1

Go inside the cases Texas will never forget.

A preacher with a deadly secret. A mother whose crime shocked a community. A death-row phone call that exposed a prison scandal. Robert Riggs takes you behind the headlines through firsthand accounts, investigations, and the pursuit of justice.

Buy the Book
Read the Story

Robert Riggs

Twenty-two-year-old Melissa Northrup, the pregnant mother of two children, vanished from a Waco convenience store in the middle of the night.

Robert Riggs

In the last episode, U.S. Marshals learned that a car belonging to a convicted triple killer was found near the site of Northrup’s kidnapping.

Robert Riggs

They didn’t believe it was just a coincidence.

Robert Riggs

The race was on to find Kenneth Allen McDuff before he could kill again.

Robert Riggs

Parnell and Mike McNamara fit the image of U.S. Marshals from the Old West tradition perfectly.

Robert Riggs

Both wore white Stetson cowboy hats, Western-cut suits, cowboy boots, holstered handguns, and steely-eyed expressions on their stone faces.

Robert Riggs

Add to this mix an aggressive U.S. attorney, one of the Marshals Service’s top manhunters, and an Irish cop from New York City, and you’ve got five men who hunt fugitives with a vengeance.

Robert Riggs

As I told you in the last episode, Marshal Parnell McNamara’s instincts told him that convicted triple killer Kenneth McDuff was responsible for the murder of Melissa Northrup.

Parnell McNamara

He was the devil himself. I mean, he was the epitome of a cold-hearted, heartless, evil, dirty son of a bitch.

Robert Riggs

The Marshals wanted to start a manhunt for McDuff. The longer he was free, the more women he would kill.

Robert Riggs

The local district attorney didn’t think there was probable cause to issue a murder warrant.

Robert Riggs

The Marshals urged U.S. Attorney Bill Johnston to help.

Robert Riggs

Johnston is now in private law practice. We sat down together to discuss the McDuff serial murder case from three decades ago.

Robert Riggs

Johnston described how he creatively obtained probable cause to get an arrest warrant to search for McDuff. He found a drug user McDuff had given one tab of LSD.

Robert Riggs

A DEA agent verified that the LSD paper wrapper had a silver palm-tree pattern sold by Austin drug dealers.

Robert Riggs

Johnston says that was all he needed.

Bill Johnston

And then the DEA guy said, “Tell me, bud, what did it do to you when you took the LSD?” And he said, “Oh, you know, I was coughing tracers.” I didn’t know what that meant. He said, “I was coughing tracers, catching my hands.” And he made a motion as if he were catching a ball between his hands, but actually he was catching his own hands because of the effect of it—“rat poison,” the LSD.

Bill Johnston

And so, in my mind, now we had a specific—we had a controlled substance which the DEA guy would say, “Yes, that is the effect of LSD,” with a specific pattern. I didn’t have the drug, but I wrote an affidavit for the DEA agent describing what the kid said. I asked the DEA guy, “Do you feel comfortable signing this probable-cause affidavit for an arrest warrant for Kenneth McDuff for distribution of one tab of LSD that we don’t have?” And he said, “Absolutely.” Because it’s a unique deal. It’s not…

Robert Riggs

Right.

Bill Johnston

It’s not like some other drug. It’s very unique. It had a pattern. So anyway, I called the federal magistrate and asked if he could see the agent. He said he would. Thirty minutes later, we had a federal arrest warrant for Kenneth Allen McDuff for distribution of one tab—which we didn’t have—of LSD. The entire Kenneth McDuff manhunt for the next six to eight weeks was based on that. That’s all the authority we had. Nobody had a murder warrant for McDuff. We had a single-tab LSD warrant, and he was chased all over the country.

Robert Riggs

Johnston and the McNamaras would work their normal hours at the federal courthouse until quitting time.

Robert Riggs

Then they would hit the street looking for McDuff in the criminal underbelly of Central Texas.

Bill Johnston

It’s so bad that if you’re in it long enough, you would be so depressed that you have to pick yourself up because it’s so negative, and it’s a slippery slide to hell, basically, the whole thing. And, yeah, it’s terrible. I mean, almost everybody we’ve talked to had been in prison. Almost everybody we talked to was on drugs or used drugs.

Robert Riggs

Johnston says Marshal Parnell McNamara and his brother Mike, who is now deceased, were a force to be reckoned with.

Bill Johnston

The McNamaras, our deputy marshals, were very unique in every respect. Their daddy had been the marshal there. Their family had been in law enforcement for a hundred years. They operated—I know this sounds really corny or silly, but if you watched the movie Tombstone and thought about how those actors portrayed the Earps and Doc Holliday, their mindset was, “We are not really afraid of anybody. We are going to try to do the right thing, even if it’s not convenient. We’re tougher than you, shoot straighter, and hit harder.” That’s the way they lived, and that’s why they were marshals. They were a throwback. Both of them were great horsemen. They dressed much like you would have a hundred years ago. I mean, not weird, but just Western.

Robert Riggs

The McNamaras drove a four-wheel-drive, jacked-up Suburban nicknamed “Big Foot.”

Robert Riggs

It was a rolling war wagon.

Robert Riggs

Parnell McNamara says his brother Mike carried a 12-gauge shotgun bolted to a military M16 machine gun with a 90-round drum magazine attached to it.

Robert Riggs

They called it the Annihilator.

Parnell McNamara

We wanted to make sure that we outgunned these scumbag punks because we knew a lot of them were armed. We armed ourselves with the very best firearms we possibly could. We had M16s, fully automatic. We had a couple of M14s, super-bad .308 machine guns. We had 12-gauge shotguns. We had 10-gauge magnum shotguns. We had the very best pistols that we could carry. So we were ready to do serious business with any of these people who wanted to give us a hard time or do something to us.

Parnell McNamara

Mike was a force to be reckoned with. People jokingly described Mike as a modern-day Doc Holliday with the—

Robert Riggs

Oh, yeah.

Parnell McNamara

—the same, you know—

Robert Riggs

Well, there was a quiet man there, but there was a volcano ready to erupt.

Parnell McNamara

Yeah, you could definitely say that. Mike was my partner in law enforcement the whole time. He and I hired on with the U.S. Marshals in 1970, the same day. Mike was right there by my side every step of the way. I never had to wonder where Mike was. Mike was also my partner in life. We went to school together, grew up together, drove the same cars, and so I totally trusted Mike to have my back. He was always there.

Robert Riggs

And you were going night and day.

Parnell McNamara

Night and day. A lot of times we were sleeping on the floor in the marshal’s office. We’d wake up in the marshal’s office, and then we’d be off and running in every direction. We followed up every single lead.

Robert Riggs

Parnell McNamara wanted the television show America’s Most Wanted to feature McDuff as a prime suspect in Melissa Northrup’s murder.

Robert Riggs

All they had was a pretty flimsy drug warrant.

Robert Riggs

Marshals Service headquarters vetoed the show.

Robert Riggs

But the service did send in the head of a task force called Operation Gunsmoke. Marshal Dan Stoltz, one of the world’s best manhunters, came to Waco.

Parnell McNamara

Then we got Dan Stoltz, who was head of the task force and an unbelievable investigator, an unbelievable marshal, a super-smart, tough guy. I can’t say enough nice things about Dan Stoltz. He came in and evaluated the situation. Mike and I and Bill and everybody else, Sheriff Pamplin, ran it down to Dan Stoltz: “This is one of the most dangerous SOBs in the country. He’s killing people as we speak, we believe that, and we’ve got to catch him. Time is running out for a lot of innocent people out there.” That’s when Dan Stoltz put the word out to Washington, D.C., that we needed help here. We needed whatever it took. We had to catch this guy.

Robert Riggs

Stoltz rolled into Waco with a command post called Red October, named after the Tom Clancy movie.

Robert Riggs

Today, Dan Stoltz raises cattle on his Texas ranch. He retired after 33 years of hunting fugitives.

Robert Riggs

Did you have a sense of how much work those three, with Bill, had done before you got there? They told me they were pretty much exhausted.

Dan Stoltz

They were the ones who ran with the ball. You’ve got to remember, nobody was really listening to them in the beginning. Nobody was listening to them, and those three ran with the ball. They didn’t have any resources. They had what there was in that little office, and that was it.

Robert Riggs

McDuff’s prison history was the starting point for Stoltz’s manhunt.

Dan Stoltz

I did a little research, and I knew him as the Broomstick Killer. So I started pulling up his stuff. The first thing I wanted to do was find out who his bunkie was, who he hung out with in prison, who would reach out. It was my experience that when someone gets caught with their hand in the cookie jar, it’s not fun unless you tell your friends that you got caught or got away with it.

Robert Riggs

The Marshals needed intelligence about McDuff’s known associates inside and outside the prison system.

Robert Riggs

John Moriarty, an undercover prison investigator, knew that world better than anyone.

Robert Riggs

When he first walked into their office, the Marshals mistook Moriarty for an ex-con.

Parnell McNamara

He came into the office, and his wealth of knowledge of the prison system was just so incredible…

Robert Riggs

At that time, he was working undercover. He looked and talked like an inmate and had almost shoulder-length hair.

Parnell McNamara

Yeah. He looked like he was out on parole himself.

Robert Riggs

Yes. Yes.

Parnell McNamara

And his language—

Robert Riggs

It was colorful, to say the least.

Parnell McNamara

Yes, I—

Robert Riggs

But he talked—he talked just like an inmate.

Parnell McNamara

Yeah, he did. The minute we heard him talk and saw him, we said, “Hey, this is our guy.”

Robert Riggs

Moriarty was a tough Irish cop from New York City, highly experienced in undercover drug investigations.

Robert Riggs

He was the only lawman in Texas history to go undercover behind bars as an inmate.

Robert Riggs

From the time we met, I regarded Moriarty as one of the few honest people trying to do the right thing inside a corrupt system.

Robert Riggs

So, were you an Irish cop walking the beat of New York City?

John Moriarty

Yeah. In fact, actually, Bergen County, New Jersey, is where I worked, right across the river from New York City.

Robert Riggs

Was there something there that prepared you for being a fugitive hunter later?

John Moriarty

I really liked working undercover in narcotics, and I never thought I would leave that job until this case.

John Moriarty

You relied on your skills and your mouth and your ability to talk to people and read people. I thought I was—I still think to this day I’m pretty good at reading people and how dangerous they are. I think it has served me well in my life so far.

Robert Riggs

Bill Johnston says Moriarty pulled back the curtain on the inner workings of the parole board and prison system.

Robert Riggs

The system tried unsuccessfully to get Moriarty to illegally divulge secret grand-jury testimony. Officials feared the feds might discover how McDuff really got out of prison on parole.

Bill Johnston

To me, he sounded like a New Jersey newspaper salesman or something. The way his accent and pace of speaking sounded was very non-Texan. He was unfamiliar to me totally, like I said—foreign to me, almost, in the way he carried himself. Then I realized, this guy has been through it. This guy has seen things. He has done some things. I didn’t know they allowed someone to go into prison undercover like that, but that’s what Moriarty did. Anyhow, I was taken by his professionalism, his toughness, everything. He was great.

Bill Johnston

And so he made our world—it was as if our world was flat, and he made it round. We were almost one-dimensional until John got involved.

Robert Riggs

Moriarty simply could not believe McDuff, a sexually deranged triple killer, had been released on parole.

Robert Riggs

Prison crowding or not, it just didn’t make sense.

John Moriarty

He was truly a sexually sadistic, psychopathic killer. I mean, he had it all.

Robert Riggs

If I had run into him on the street—he worked in a convenience store at one point—would I have gotten any sense of how dangerous he was?

John Moriarty

No, not—he wouldn’t be a threat to you. I mean, he was only a threat to women he would target. He got along—he wasn’t— a lot of people didn’t like him, but when I teach a class on interviewing and interrogating career criminals, I talk about guys like McDuff. When you’re interviewing him and talking to him and he’s looking at you, all he’s thinking is, “How is what’s coming out of your mouth going to benefit me?” Period. That’s all. That’s what you’ve got to remember when you talk to these guys, because they don’t care. They don’t have a conscience. They don’t care about anything but themselves. And that’s absolutely true.

Robert Riggs

Next on True Crime Reporter: Just as Sheriff Larry Pamplin predicted after hearing about McDuff getting out of prison on parole, more women are disappearing. More bodies are showing up.

Bill Johnston

During this timeframe, there was another victim found near the technical school campus, Valencia Joshua from Fort Worth. She was found. We were out there for that. That’s where I found a grave McDuff had pre-dug near where Valencia Joshua was buried.

Robert Riggs

To follow True Crime Reporter, text TRUE CRIME to 33777. Text TRUE CRIME to 33777.

Bill Johnston

And you were hearing that he was always asking people about, or commenting that, it would be a good place to bury a body.

Bill Johnston

Right. It was as if, in his mind, when he looked over—driving down the road, looking out at the scenery—he saw it as a gravedigger, more like some predatory animals. They kill something and drag it someplace, find a tree or something, or partially bury it to save it for themselves. That was the way he saw geography.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

How did Bill Johnston obtain a federal arrest warrant for McDuff?

Johnston said he used an account from a person who had taken a tab of LSD McDuff gave him, a DEA agent’s identification of the wrapper’s distinctive pattern, and an affidavit to obtain a warrant for LSD distribution.

Did the posse have a murder warrant for McDuff?

No. Johnston said the team had a federal warrant for distribution of one tab of LSD, not a murder warrant. He said the manhunt operated under that authority for six to eight weeks.

Who was John Moriarty?

Moriarty was an undercover prison investigator with experience in undercover narcotics work. The McNamaras brought him into the search because he knew the prison system and its networks.

Who joined the Texas posse searching for McDuff?

The team included Deputy U.S. Marshals Parnell and Mike McNamara, U.S. Attorney Bill Johnston, Marshals Service fugitive hunters, and John Moriarty, an undercover prison investigator.