Parnell McNamara
A very beautiful young 17 year old high school girl walking home from a party one night, the day before school started, she disappeared. She never made it home. Her body was found several days later in a ditch shot multiple times in the head and the heart just discarded like a piece of garbage. So sad. It was never solved until we got the cold case unit going.
Sheriff Parnell McNamara promised his constituents in McLennan County, Texas around Waco that he would actively pursue cold cases.
McNamara was elected for a third four-year term in January of 2021. And he has made good on his campaign pledge to open up homicide cases that had been long forgotten.
Because as McNamara sees it no one should get away with murder and the victim’s family deserves to know what happen.
This is Robert Riggs covering Texas crime stories that are stranger than fiction.
The McNamara clan started in law enforcement in 1902 with Guy McNamara who President Franklin Roosevelt later appointed as a U.S. Marshal in 1933.
You may recall from our earlier episodes about serial killer Kenneth McDuff, that it was the brothers, Deputy U.S. MarshalsParnell and Mike McNamara that launched the manhunt for McDuff with my co host former U.S. prosecutor Bill Johnston.
After 36 years with the U.S. Marshals Service, Parnell McNamara reached the mandatory retirement age.
He retired for nine years but was not willing to be put out to pasture as they say here in Texas.
He was elected Sheriff in 2011 on a campaign slogan of “Riding Herd on the Lawless.”
McNamara wearing his trademark Stetson cowboy hat is a throwback to the old West.
The western historical decor in his office looks like a modern day Dodge City occupied by Wyatt Earp.
I sat down to talk to Sheriff McNamara and the Captain of his cold case unit Steve January.
They started by giving me a challenge coin for the unit.
It features the “Dead Man’s Hand In Poker”, the combination of cards that “Wild Bill” Hickok was holding when he was shot dead point blank in the back of the head.
Like I said this is the old west where McNamara still forms a posse to hunt down fugitives.
And one more thing. McNamara was the inspiration for Jeff Bridge’s role in Come Hell or High Water which was written by his cousin Taylor Sheridan, best known now for Yellowstone.
Saddle up your horse. Here’s my interview from inside the crime scene tape with Sheriff Parnell McNamara.
Sheriff McNamara, you came into office with a campaign promise to start a cold case unit. Why were you so passionate about doing that?
Parnell January
Well, I realized that there were a lot of unsolved murders, very brutal homicides in this area. And I knew that some of them hadn't even been looked at in years. And that was very disturbing to me. The sheriff's office did not have a cold case unit, there was really nobody actively looking at these cases on a regular basis. So I wanted to form a unit that would be dedicated to solving these brutal murders and not have to be distracted by other police work. And
Robert Riggs
I've seen this across the country where there's a huge backlog of cases. It's like there must be a lot of people getting away with murder.
Parnell January
Absolutely. And that was, that was what was so disturbing to us when we started looking into it. And once I formed the cold case, unit, I put Captain Steve January, who was Captain over our Criminal Investigation Division, which handles homicides and robberies and so forth. I put him in charge is the commander of the cold case unit. And I said go to the files, go to the records and get the files out. And let's see how many homicides we have here that are unsolved and like you say people literally have gotten away with murder.
Robert Riggs
Well, Captain January, Captain Steve, January is here with us. When you went to those files, what did you find? Were you shocked? Were you what?
Steve January
Yeah, we found files underneath cabinets. Until the sheriff's a mum had dust on them and hadn't been looked at or read or touched in years. And it was it was disturbing, because there are people out there that are getting away with murder, and the victim's families. Some of these cases, law enforcement had not ever even talked, sit down and talk with the families is what we found out. In one case, the sheriff put his own first we we interviewed 63 People from 37 years ago at that time now it's been a few more years since then. It was a 1982 murder. And we actually had them in this very room and sat down the whole family for over two hours, and told them everything that we'd found out and everybody that we'd interviewed. And the joy for us is that we get to share that information with a family when nobody's ever talked to them. And the mother of the victim that case made a comment that we put on our challenge coin, she said she told the sheriff she said thank you for answering our unanswered questions. And so we adopted that and put that on our our challenge calling for colocation,
Robert Riggs
Sheriff bank, no matter what was there about that case? And what were the questions that needed to be answered?
Parnell January
Well, that was a case where a very beautiful young 17 year old high school girl walking home from a party one night, the day before school started, she disappeared. She never made it home. Her body was found several days later in a ditch shot multiple times in the head and the heart just discarded like a piece of garbage. So sad. It was never solved until we got the cold case unit going. And we're able to solve it. And it was not solved with DNA. It was solved by just basic police work on the part of our detectives, like the captain said they interviewed 63 individuals, and finally found a witness that saw the killer that night covered in blood and and we were able to solve that.
Robert Riggs
Were you able to get to the bottom of why no one had done police work on this case.
Parnell January
Well, they had done police work in the past there were some officers that looked at him. And just were not able to put it together. And I don't want to talk disparaging about him because some of them were good officers. But this the cold case unit and Captain January have a wealth of knowledge in homicide investigations. That's what the captain did when he was with waco PD and we hired another individual from another police department that taught crime scene investigations and he still teaches forensic science, criminal science at Baylor and So these guys are experts in that field, and they were able to put everything together and solve this case.
Robert Riggs
We're Captain January, I think a lot of the public today thinks this is easy with DNA. Explain what I call the shoe leather, the boot leather version of knocking on doors and going places. Give us a sense what really is involved in a homicide investigation?
Steve January
Well, you you, first of all, the information that a lot of times is really cold, the witnesses you have to track down all over the country. One example on one case, we were actually two examples, we go to Fort Smith, Arkansas and interview a person that never talked to police. And she was glad we were there and want to tell her story. And she solved one of the murder cases just because she witnessed she was boyfriend girlfriend with a murderer at that time. Another one we we fly to Tennessee and interview a person that never spoke to the officers. And my point is she she gave us some dynamite information on another homicide that she had witnessed that night. We have the technology now that we can find people, no matter where they move to one of our suspects has moved out of the country, we know that we're contemplating on trying to see if we can go out of the country to interview that person. But the sheriff has provided us the the tools in which we can be successful. He allows us to go wherever we need to go wherever we need to go and stay as long as we need to get to stay there to accomplish it, to do the interviews or to do the investigation. And I think last year in 2021, he allowed us to go to at least six different states. And we get a lot of support from the citizens in McLennan County. They have provided donations to our colocation if they want to be a part of something that you know, is helping other citizens get answers to their loved ones deaths.
Robert Riggs
Sheriff, I know you you've made a number of trips, Rios, tell us about that case, if you can talk about it.
Parnell January
That is a case where an individual we know murdered his wife stuffed her in the trunk of a car in 1985. And so it's been unsolved. We finally located him, we know where he is. We have gotten DNA and we're it's an active case. I can't say a whole lot more about it now. But I personally went out with the our officers twice to Ruidoso. And like the captain said, we have had such incredible support from our citizens. Lady just came in and gave us $6,000 for travel expenses. Couple of months ago, Taylor Sheridan and his family producer of Yellowstone gave us 5000 other citizens have given us 1000s of dollars. So when we get a lead in another state, we don't have to send the information to another police department. We go ourself,
Robert Riggs
I'm gonna go off on a tangent and maybe you have a special connection to Taylor Sheridan, who is incredibly popular right now in Hollywood for not only Yellowstone 1883 and more things coming.
Parnell January
Yes, Taylor's my cousin, and I watched him grow up. He's probably 1518 years younger than I am, and whale of a cowboy. And so is his wife, Nicole. Taylor. Taylor's father actually grew up just right across the street from my family when we were in elementary school and all that. And then Taylor's dad married my cousin. And that's, that's how we're related. And so I watched Taylor, you know, grow up from a kid to what he is now. And he's an incredible writer, as we all know,
Robert Riggs
well, as you know, my wife is a cow girl. Yes, horses and we're watching Yellowstone and you see the Quarter Horse sliding and her friends didn't know that was Taylor on there. And that's called raining. They had no idea that he's a real cowboy.
Parnell January
Yeah, he really is. And that's an incredibly difficult sport to train those horses to slide and spin around like they do. Taylor is a master at that. And he's also an incredible cutting horse rider. And he's, he's a ranch guy. He's also been inducted into the Texas cowboy Hall of Fame in March of 2021. And so we were in Fort Worth for that.
Robert Riggs
So for our audience, that's a little bit of tech Santa for you. But back to the cold case is still What has been the the most interesting case you've taken on?
Steve January
Probably the most interesting was the first one. Because it was so complex as far as the interviews and connecting and on all of our cold cases, we put together a PowerPoint presentation for grand juries. And we do have currently four indictments with local DEA on cases that are still pending. But the first one, when you put together the PowerPoint of all the different characters that were involved, and there were multiple suspects that we had to rule out because sometimes other investigators, they they pull people into an investigation, and they never resolved the fact that they they weren't the person that did it. So as we went through that case, it took months and months. And it was very satisfying, because of all the, the answers we got for ourself and for the family. And for the innocent people that had been falsely accused. There were some people that were falsely accused by law enforcement back in the 80s, of doing that crime. And we we resolve those issues. And, you know, the family's gratitude toward us it, it just it runs cold chills over you and brings tears to your eyes. Sometimes if you would have been in this room where we presented all those interviews and facts and circumstances to them. It just, it just it's hardly talked about some time you get choked up a little bit. 17 year old girl, like he said it was a student here locally. And she had a laugh ahead of her. And during the interview in this room right here, there was her mother, her dad had died. Her mother had remarried. And of course, she's grown Oh, grew old, sorry about the wording. Her sister was here, her brother was here. their significant others were here. And I think a niece was here. They had about eight people in this room. And that was probably the most impactful investigation I've had. Other than when I worked at Waco PD, it was what it waco PD, it meant a lot to me. But as far as cold cases, that's got to be my favorite. The first one.
Parnell January
I would like to add a little bit to that. Thank you Captain. One of the things that stood out about our first case, when we got into it, we notified the family that we were looking into this case, and the mother literally broke down on the phone and couldn't believe that we were still interested in the case. She said I can't believe that. Beth was not forgotten. We thought she had been forgotten all these years. And we said absolutely not. And I said we're going to do everything we can to solve this case. And that was rewarding to me, just to hear the parents of this young girl that was so brutally murdered, innocently walking home trying to get home after this party. And the ride that had taken her didn't have enough gasoline to get her home. So she said I'll just walk. And CoreSite was our last walk and with the fact that it touched them so much to know that law enforcement had not forgotten her. And they were still trying meant the world to the family. And then when we brought him in and explained everything, they said, we really never thought Joe would be able to convince us that you solve this, but now we know you did.
Robert Riggs
So what was the reaction of the killer when you put the cuffs on him?
Steve January
Well, on that particular case, the killer was already passed away. And so we weren't able to make an arrest on that case. But everybody in the room, all the investigators, the sheriff, the family knew that if he was alive, we would have been able to put them in a courtroom and got a conviction out of him. You know, it's sad that he had passed away a few years prior to our solvent. It was just a few years probably three years before we we solved it that he had passed away.
Robert Riggs
So you you talked about the officers get emotional over these now I'm going to describe for the audience. You're both wearing cowboy hats, western boots, jeans, Western belts, gun big gun belts. You both are tough looking guys and hard i somebody look at you not expect you to get emotional. But you do.
Parnell January
Absolutely. We're supposed to be big tough. Oh man. But sometime maybe we're not these things touches When innocent people are hurt or murdered and families are devastated. It hits us all real hard. And so that said strengthens our resolve to solve these cases. And so, you know, when we're talking to the family, we may have tears rolling on our face, too. And it's, it's so emotional. And it is such a bad thing that is happened when these innocent people, most of them, not in the bad part of town, not late at night, just the wrong place at the wrong time, like Beth Bramblett, walking down the street trying to get home and gets picked up. This happened to be one of her neighbors. And I'm sure he offered to give her a ride she got in the car, and then she was beaten very badly before she was shot and killed. And so it was unfortunate that we didn't get him before he died. We would have done everything we could to put him in prison for life or getting the deaths and
Robert Riggs
it's and yet it was a neighbor who she would have trusted to get in the car with
Parnell January
Yes, it was actually the father of one of her friends so to speak. And we're pretty sure that that's that's what happened. But once he got her in the car, we feel like he drove past her house. And she confronted him, hey, that's where I live. And then he started abusing or beaten her and then eventually shot her and threw her out in the ditch. Very sad.
Robert Riggs
We're gonna pause for a moment for a message from our sponsor. We'll be right back after this. We're back now. I'm Robert Riggs, talking with Sheriff Parnell McNamara the McLennan, county sheriff in Waco, Texas, and the head of cold cases. Captain Steve January. You had a case here that was interesting in that the person was threatening real estate agents, but he had lots and lots of personal information about him. Did you work on this? Steve, as as
Steve January
one of my investigators worked on it? If you're talking about the guy out of Lubbock? Yes, yes.
Robert Riggs
Tell us about that case. Because that seemed like a nightmare for any real estate agent or person getting a call. And what would he say when he called and how did he get the info?
Steve January
A lot of the real estate people post these billboards and they post their picture. They post their office numbers, cell phone numbers, and I think I didn't interview him. And I don't think he really talked to our investigators after the rest about it. But he would pick a city. And I think there were 20 cities in 10 Different states that he was actually doing this in where he was harassing it most of the time, it was vulgar or sexual in nature. And he was obtaining the cell phone numbers and he would communicate and we were able to track him back through cell phone tower information and also locations and and that he he you know, he was doing this hour but location in when we tracked it back. It came right back to him. I don't want to really divulge our Yeah, our techniques of locating them, but we did and it was him. I think he was just a pervert, I think he was I don't know how dangerous he was to the people that he was calling here in McLennan County. However, it was later found out that he had committed a couple of murders that were cold cases in another city in Texas. And that is still ongoing, though.
Robert Riggs
And Sheriff give us a little more detail. You talked about how he would even husbands would get on the line. He didn't threaten the husband and tell him to get off
Parnell January
and yes, he certainly would. And he was spoofing area codes and it would show up like he was calling from Los Angeles or San Francisco or you know, Alabama, Georgia somewhere other states. And he made a mistake on one thing and we were able to track it back to him and pinpoint him in Lubbock. And so we sent our fast unit to Lubbock, got him arrested, brought him back to McLennan County and while he was here, DNA was matched up that he was the killer of a two brutal murders in Lubbock back in, I guess, what, 18 or 20 years ago, and so very lucky there that was a good DNA hit. But our our Criminal Investigation Division was the one that solved that case and but he was yes, he was threatening him. He was just a sick sob and he was is doing all kinds of sexual innuendos and threatening the husbands and threatening to kill them or threatening to do all kinds of bodily harm to them.
Robert Riggs
So it's a long way from Waco, Lubbock, Texas. There are a lot of departments that would never spend the money to do that. But y'all did.
Parnell January
Absolutely. We can't read any county line signs. I can't read state line signs. And so
Robert Riggs
what I need to explain for our listeners is that often your jurisdiction is at the border of the county.
Parnell January
That's correct. But we go wherever we're needed. And so we traveled all over the state. We have gone into many other states. A lot of our investigators are deputized as US Marshals, so they have federal cred. So we have a couple that are commissioned under Homeland Security that have federal jurisdiction. So there's all kinds of ways we can do this. But wherever we're needed, we work with other agencies, we don't just go into somebody else's jurisdiction on announced we always work with the local police there and but that's how we're able to solve these cold cases is these men kept in January and Detective hitch are dedicated 24/7 to the cold case, they don't have to pull off and do anything else. And so that's why they're successful and then go anywhere.
Robert Riggs
Now you not a you not only got other states in the United States, you've recently had an officer in Poland or response to the sex trafficking crisis coming out of Ukraine. Yes, I suppose what what is happening there, what
Parnell January
is the what is happening in Poland is happening all over the world, and human trafficking is rampant everywhere. And we had no idea how bad it was till we formed a human trafficking unit here in 2014. And so our investigator that our lead investigator Joe scare Moochie has gone all over the United States training, other police departments. He's gone into Mongolia training the Mongolian police. And these are invitations to McLennan County to police come help and train us what y'all are doing. So he was asked, or McLennan County was asked to go to Poland, and help the Polish police recognize people that were being trafficked as soon as the Ukrainians were coming across the border, because the men are required to stay in Ukraine and fight. So you have the women and their kids, beautiful girls coming across young kids. And so the victims are just ripe for this trafficking. And so while scare Moochie was there in Poland, he was also going into Ukraine. And he and the border police recognized and identified several Russians that were operating in on the Ukrainian Polish border, and trying to grab these women and kids, they even identified a an American that was involved in the trafficking from a state over here. And so they're going to be dealing with him. So basically, that's what we were doing. And people say, Why are you sending somebody you know, out of state or out of the country, if we can help solve this problem in any way before it gets to McLennan County, whether it be drugs, or trafficking or whatever, that that's our goal. If we can help other agencies or other States or other countries, we're gonna go, I've given our guys a green light. And let go.
Robert Riggs
Did you find the sex traffickers are also now trying to smuggle? The people they've been trapped through our southern border of Texas? Oh, absolutely.
Parnell January
Absolutely. It's rampant. What is happening there is a travesty against humanity. And these people that are caused this north of us here should have their head in shame. They ought to find a big rock and crawl under it, because they have created a horrible situation on the border, not just for our border patrol or DPS or sheriffs and law enforcement down there, but also for innocent people that want to come across illegally, but they're being trafficked by the cartels. And it's putting a lot of people specially our people or law enforcement in big time Jeopardy.
Robert Riggs
Other co cases that stand out that you're particularly proud of the background on
Steve January
proud of one that we have indicted keep talking about the details, but we haven't indict No, hold on that person and we're trying to pull them out of another country as we speak we we have to have some help though, getting provisional warrants and stuff that we're pretty proud of that one that was there were probably 33 print 33 people present in the area when it happened over the period of the last 20, renounce about 28 years, there have been five of them that had passed away, but we located 28 of the 3326 of the witnesses are still in McLennan County, the other two are still in Texas. And so that's, that gives you a lot of pride when you are able to locate all those folks from that far back, get an indictment, and know that when you actually put the handcuffs on him and drag him back to McLennan County, that we will get a conviction on it. There's no doubt
Parnell January
this individual that he's talking about, shot four people in front of a big crowd. He killed one he crippled one for life who's still in a wheelchair. Two of them recovered. And so very brutal act. And we're going to do everything we can to get him back in the country and make him accountable for what he's done.
Robert Riggs
Sheriff for our listeners, how can they help you? I know you are your you take contributions, where do they send it? And what will it do for you?
Parnell January
Well, if somebody wants to make a contribution to the sheriff's Cold Case, unit, they just make a check out to McLennan, county sheriff's cold case unit, it goes straight into an account that is used for traffic, you know, for for traveling motels, gas, lodging, and all land for our guys to go follow up on these leads. And that's one way that's been a huge help, we would not have been able to do what we've done if the public hadn't stepped up and given us the funds to travel and follow up on these leads.
Robert Riggs
And I know there's advanced DNA techniques that are really helpful in these cases. But Captain January, I mean, they're expensive.
Steve January
They are expensive. And eventually we may have to use some of these funds to go toward an outside agency other than agencies we use right now that do it for free, like DPS. We are considered a couple of cases, the DNA is expensive. But it's a it's a way of life now that these other individuals that have DNA labs that are developing new techniques and new databases to search the DNA for are going to have to be utilized because the state and the federal databases are not going to be sufficient to do all these cases. But having said that, yes, it is expensive. And these funds may end up going toward the you know, the financing of some DNA work outside of those agencies.
Parnell January
One thing if I may want to give our guys credit, a lot of these cases happen before DNA. They're going back and pulling up all the evidence out of the lockers and are able to get some DNA that you know back in the day back in the 80s. Nobody knew really what DNA was nobody was using it. And mainly fingerprints and blood types and that type of thing. So we're able to go back and get clothing, get DNA off of clothing and different items, beer cans or whatever the cigarettes may have been found at the scene and matching that DNA up there.
Robert Riggs
Share Parnell McNamara and Captain Steve January. Thank you so much for talking about your cold case unit again, in our show notes I'm going to put in their information about where you could send a contribution to the McLennan, county sheriff's cold case unit and I would say in conclusion here this is an example of the long arm of the Texas law.
Parnell January
Absolutely.
Robert Riggs
Thank you both. Thank you. Okay, can I just get about 30 seconds? Yeah, we just say you're quiet Okay, great. That was good. So far our listeners, you know that we've done a number of episodes about cold cases. So we're going to do a test and see if we can try to crowdsource a case where those of you who are passionate have about cold cases and kind of look at this as a hobby and you're maybe you're retired you have time on your hands. We're going to to kind of develop a process where you could help on a cold case for the McLennan County Sheriff Parnell McNamara and the head of the cold case unit Captain Steve January and captain, tell us about the victim in this case and how you need help.
Steve January
Currently, we're looking for the body. I'm sorry. Currently, we're looking for a body belonging to a boy named Justin O'Brien. He disappeared in May of 2002. We're absolutely convinced that he was murdered here in McLennan County. But we're trying to locate his body
Robert Riggs
and share back to Mary you've already devoted a lot of resources to this. Absolutely. Yes, we have. And what do you think is the footwork or the maybe the keyboard work our some of our listeners could do to try to help find a missing person.
Parnell January
Just if they have any information or any connection to McLennan County, are any information that they may be able to develop concerning the disappearance of Justin O'Brien, please contact us, let us know we will follow up on every single lead every bit of information that we get.
Robert Riggs
Alright, so for our listeners, you know, we've had a number of cold case episodes, you probably heard me may remember David Thornton, who set up the cold case unit in Fort Worth, which led to the solving a 47 year old murder of a 17 year old Carla Walker. So he's going to help us with a process we're going to vet you. But we're going to try to build a process of how you wherever you live, could get online and try to help. So I want to ask you to stay tuned. There'll be things in our show notes. And we'll be posting on our blog post at our website true crime reporter.com. And again, this is your chance to try to help solve a missing person case where there's a body and they got to find out who done it.
Parnell January
Absolutely. And we appreciate any information that we could get.