Troy Wigley Inmate:
As many times as I walked into a court room at an evidentiary hearing I usually hear the saying from the Assistant Attorney General here he comes, Perry Mason.
A convicted rapist who hammered a knife into his victimâs skull brags that he is the Texas prison systemâs version of the fictional defense attorney, Perry Mason.
Hello I am investigative reporter Robert Riggs here with another true crime story that is stranger than fiction.
In this episode of True Crime ReporterÂŽ, I have dusted off my reporterâs notebook for a series of stories I broke in back 1994 called âConvictâs Court.â
Texas prison inmates literally clogged up the federal court system by filing 4400 frivolous lawsuits in 1993 alone.
How frivolous?
A convicted felon sued because of air bubbles in his peanut butter.
Another prisoner claimed he suffered mental anguish caused by a burned-out light bulb.
An inmate sued because he could not wear socks in the shower.
Another wanted 45-thousand dollars in damages because guards confiscated his pornographic magazines which had been smuggled in as contraband.
A prisoner even alleged that he suffered from malnourishment because his deserts crumbled in the dining hall. A federal judge dismissed that case noting that the inmate had gained 22 pounds since he arrived in prison.
It drove then Texas Attorney General Dan Morales crazy
Dan Morales
They are essentially I think using every technical opportunity that they have to gum up the works. And I think that crime victims and law enforcement officials who see the complaints about cold food and toilet paper not soft enough. I certainly can understand how they would feel that this is indeed, making a mockery of our criminal justice system.
Inmate Troy Wigley, the self described Perry Mason of the Texas prison system sued for nearly two million dollars because he could not change the TV channels, had to use plastic utensils in the dining hall, complained that his Thanksgiving turkey dinner was served cold, and he wanted weight lifting equipment plus a pool table in the prison.
A federal judge dismissed Wigleyâs lawsuit but it cost Texas taxpayers 1700-dollars to defend it.
Wigley
As many times as I walked into a court room at an evidentiary hearing I usually hear the saying from the Assistant Attorney General here he comes, Perry Mason.
Riggs Q.
Perry Mason always wins. Do you always win?
Wigley.
No I haven't won yet but
I've gained lots of knowledge. I've gained lots of experience and a lot of respect from the courts.
â
I interviewed Wigley in a maximum security prisonâs administrative segregation unit where he was held in solitary confinement because of his violent behavior.
Guards dutifully delivered law books to his cell every day to compy with U.S. Supreme Court rulings.
Wigley
You as a taxpayer itâs driving you crazy that I am being allowed to receive law books and things of that sort.
Wigley was serving a life sentence for raping a woman and then hammering a knife into her skull. He spotted a family member leaving a key under the front doormat.
Wigly used the key to get inside. Hid in the attic. When the suburban housewife came home, Wigley plunged through the sheetrock ceiling for his blitz attack.
His victim barely survived and it took 600 stitches to close her knife wounds.
Wigley felt no guilt because his victim received 25-thousand dollars from the state victimâs compensation fund to pay her medical bills.
Wigley
They too are awarded some money for just being a victim.
Riggs Q
You think that would just take care of everything? The pain and suffering?
Wigley:
I think that it would even out the score and I think it would place some burden on the state.
Riggs:
Now how about your victim. Would it even the score on your victim?
Wigley:
Well I think it would have, it would have compensated the victim in my case.
{----------}
As I said at the beginning of this episode our true crime stories are stranger than fiction.
We will be back after this message from our sponsor.
(Commercial Break)
My quest to find the most frivalous of all inmate lawsuits took me inside the maximum security Hughes prison unit to talk to Inmate Dan Thomas.
Thomas had filed 133 lawsuits one because his Rice Crispieâs cereal did not go Snap, Crackle, Pop. I kid you not.
Thomas had to duck to get his massive muscular body through the door to the visitation room where I waited to interview him.
He was originally sentenced to fours years for drug possession. But 39 more years had been tacked on to his sentence for assaulting guards.
Face to face, I put the question to Thomas about his frivolous snap, crackle, pop lawsuit expecting him to grab me by the throat.
But Thomas just smiled with a twinkle in his eye and answered.
Inmate Dan Thomas
I did read in the full service manual that we are supposed to get a one ounce serving and the boxes we had were less than an ounce.
Riggs Q
So the box that you did get. Did it have any snap crackl pop?
Dan Thomas
I assume it did.
Inmates used expensive prison libraries to sow what prison officials called legal terrorism. Higher court orders dictated the brightness of the light fixtures and required cool air conditioning for the inmates.
William Spaulding, a former cellmate of serial killer Kenneth McDuff who we have talked about in earlier episodes, temporarily stopped the construction of an addition his prison unit.
All because it was going to be built on his favorite prison softball field.
Spaulding took me inside his cell where he had neatly stacked hundreds of documents from his lawsuit.
William Spaulding:
I take the softball fields real personal.
Spaulding also filed a legal complaint that prison took too long to serve inmateâs their meals in the dining hall.
And I for one do not want to be the last man fed after three hours.
Riggs
The public doesnâ have a lot of sympathy that you canât play softball now or you have got to wait in line for food?
Spaulding
If you let these inmates sit around and brew somewhere down the line you are going to have a lot of trouble. I know the public doesnât look at that and they donât even really want to hear this. What prison life is all about. Because I have been on prison units where we didnât have recreation. And everybody was gnawing at one another and there were a lot of fights generated.
Some innmates also started suing their victims.
Twice convicted killer Fred Ebenal claimed that the woman he murdered with a shotgun was his common law wife.
I later discovered he was in fact married to a California woman.
But Ebenal sued to get 15-thousand dollars from his 59 year old victimâs estate.
Riggs
Since you were convicted of killing her how could you want or think you deserve the money?
Fred Ebenal
Because I broke the law does this give them the right to break the law and take a man's life savings away.
Ebenalâs lawsuit outraged Ken and Shana Freeman, the victimâs son and daugher in law.
Shanna Freeman
Its enough that a family should God forbid ever have to endure a member of their family being killed in any way but to be cold bloodedly killed the way she was
And then for him to do this, it's just unbelievable. It's just totally unbelievable.
Indeed the frivolous cases were unbelievable.
After interviewing dozens of inmates, I discovered that many of them were filing lawsuits just to get out of their cells for a day to ride in the prison van to federal court.
Federal judges curbed the filing of frivalous lawsuits by putting remote TV cameras in the prisons to conduct their hearings.
The inmates brief taste of freedom on the sightseeing trip to the federal courthouse ended.
But to this day as I pour milk over my Rice Crisipies I always listen for the sound of Snap, Crackle, Pop.