A Former 48 Hours Producer Reveals the Psychology and Power Behind the Genre
By Robert Riggs
When I sat down with Claire St. Amant on my True Crime Reporter® podcast, I wasn’t expecting a masterclass in the psychology of violence. But that’s exactly what I got.
As a former producer for 48 Hours and 60 Minutes, Claire has spent years digging into America’s darkest stories—and now, she’s written a memoir that lifts the curtain on true crime television: Killer Story: The Truth Behind True Crime Television.
With our shared background covering crime in Texas, it didn’t take long for the conversation to get personal, chilling, and revealing.
The Female Obsession with Murder
“Why is true crime so popular with women?” I asked. It’s the question I hear most often, whether at a book signing or on the trail of a story.
Claire didn’t hesitate.
“It’s a safe way to consume all the terrible things that could happen to us,” she explained. “Women are statistically more likely to be the victims of violent crime. And many of the victims in these stories are just like us.”
The draw is primal. A protective instinct. Watching, listening, absorbing details as a way to prepare for what might lurk around the next corner.
“There’s a sense of control,” Claire told me. “Even if the story is terrifying, it’s still unfolding at a distance. That distance is everything.”
The Seeds of Violence: Nature vs. Nurture
We both nodded when the inevitable serial killer question came up—nature or nurture?
Claire sees it as a cocktail of both.
“Some people are born with violent tendencies. But what really shapes them is whether they’re taught to embrace or manage those tendencies,” she said.
It’s not just killers that concern her. It’s the larger societal breakdown. Youth gun violence. Road rage that turns deadly.
“People don’t grow up,” she said, her voice tightening. “They act like toddlers throwing tantrums—except now they have a knife or a gun in their hands.”
Launching a Career Through a Killer’s Lies
Claire’s own true crime journey began with the story of Michelle Williams—a Texas woman who wore the mask of an innocent widow while manipulating the justice system.
“She was about to walk free with a nine-year plea deal,” Claire recalled. “But I found a pattern. Her story didn’t hold up.”
Digging into Michelle’s past revealed lies stacked like dominoes. It was her third husband. Her second suicide claim. And Claire’s reporting set off a media firestorm.
“After my story, the plea was pulled. She was tried and sentenced to 60 years.”
That one investigation launched Claire’s career in television. But more importantly, it delivered justice that had nearly slipped away.
The Haunting Faces of Samuel Little
One of Claire’s most unforgettable assignments came at 60 Minutes, when she helped uncover the chilling story of Samuel Little—the most prolific serial killer in U.S. history.
With the help of a Texas Ranger, Little confessed to 93 murders. And he didn’t just confess—he drew his victims. Eerie, intimate sketches of the women he strangled.
“Those portraits helped identify Jane Does,” Claire said. “Family members would see a sketch and say, ‘That’s my mother.’”
Inside Little’s prison cell, Claire saw the unsettling shrine he had built: fan mail, drawings, and snacks. It looked more like a summer camp cabin than the lair of a killer.
“It was eerie,” she told me. “Disturbing to know that was where he reclined.”
Love Letters to Killers
Why do some women fall for these monsters?
“There’s a strange psychology to it,” Claire said. “They’re drawn to the idea of a ‘powerful’ man who can’t hurt them because he’s locked away. It’s an emotional relationship that feels safe.”
The paradox is as twisted as the killers themselves. For some, it’s a romantic fantasy; for others, a misguided form of control.
Lessons from the Police Beat
Claire got her start on the police beat—covering crimes that unfolded in the early hours, long before the rest of the world stirred.
“It’s a trial by fire,” she said. “You’re dealing with death, trauma, and people who don’t want to talk. But you learn fast. And you learn what matters.”
From local police blotters to national investigations, she traced patterns in crime and character. It was the beginning of a lifelong obsession with truth, with justice, and with storytelling.
The Power and Pitfalls of Crime TV
Television crime stories follow a formula: five or six acts, cliffhangers before commercials, and a resolution by the end. It’s digestible drama designed for prime time.
“The viewer walks away feeling safer,” Claire said. “But real life doesn’t always tie up so neatly.”
In contrast, Claire’s podcast—Final Days on Earth—lets her dive deeper.
“If a story takes ten episodes, we do ten episodes. There’s freedom in that.”
What makes a great true crime story?
“I look for those moments that change everything—new evidence, new testimony, a total reversal of what you thought you knew.”
But even as criminals try to get smarter, technology is catching up. Fitbits, toll tags, license plate readers. Claire sees a digital trail in nearly every case.
Advice for Staying Safe
Claire’s warning is clear:
“Your intimate partner is your biggest risk. If you’re scared of the person next to you, get out now.”
She also cautions about people you let into your home—contractors, cleaners, anyone with access.
“Have cameras. Let them know you have cameras. And a big barking dog doesn’t hurt either.”
Final Words
We ended our interview where many true crime stories begin: the Texas Rangers.
With their iconic hats and cross-state jurisdiction, they’re more than myth. They’re elite investigators who quietly reopen cold cases and follow leads long after others have moved on.
“You won’t see them at the press conference,” Claire noted. “But they’re often the reason it happened.”
With more than 300,000 cold cases in the U.S.—and over 1,000 in Fort Worth alone—the Rangers have their work cut out.
But like Claire said, “The crime beat never sleeps.”
Neither do we.
Subscribe to my “Stories To Keep You Safe” Newsletter
In a world where evil often walks among us, disguised by the ordinary, vigilance is critical. As someone who has seen what happens when people are caught off guard, I am on a mission to provide you with the knowledge that could one day save your life.
Stories to Keep You Safe arms you with the insights you won’t find in the daily news—because I know that criminals don’t always look dangerous, and every step you take could make the difference between being a target and staying safe.
I also warn you about the latest threats from Artificial Intelligence and dangerous products.
Purchase my Books
“Texas Crime Stories” audiobook. It downloads into your podcast app.
Paperback & Kindle editions on Amazon.
This blood-chilling true-crime anthology peels back the curtain on some of Texas’s most disturbing and unforgettable criminal cases. From cold-blooded murder to unspeakable betrayal, each story dives deep into the hearts of both victims and perpetrators, unearthing the truths buried beneath public headlines and official accounts.
Schedule Me To Speak at your social meeting or corporate event.
My presentation, “Evil Walks Among Us,” features stories about serial killers, infamous criminals, cold cases, and personal safety tips.
GET YOUR EXCLUSIVE DISCOUNT PROMO CODES
41% Off Cozy Earth Sheets, Pajamas and More
20% Off Eric Javits Designer Hats Worn by True Crime TV Detectives
20% Off HyperNatural Men’s Polo Shirts
15% Off TONA Activewear Designer Gym Leggings
15% Off STAND+ Comfort Shoes For Extended Standing
10% Off AKILA Sunglasses and Eyewear
