Robert Riggs:
A Houston television station ran a regular news feature titled âCity Under Siege.â
It was no exaggeration.
In 1990, the entire state of Texas was under siege.
My reporterâs notebook and newspaper clipping file illustrate the crime problem.
In Houston, an ex-con and his accomplice ran low on gas. So they carjacked a woman stopped at a traffic signal.
The ex-con shot the 22-year-old mother in the face with a .30-caliber carbine. He pulled her from behind the wheel, ran over her body for good measure, and sped away with a full tank of gas.
The parole board had released her killer three weeks earlier.
During a routine traffic stop, an ex-con stepped out and took aim with a .357-caliber revolver. He squeezed off rounds into a motorcycle officerâs chest.
He calmly walked around the car, stood over the officer, and fired two more slugs into his head.
The parole board had turned the killer loose from prison a month earlier.
His rap sheet listed seven prior felony convictions. He had served only 13 months of a 15-year sentence for sexually assaulting a child before he was allowed to walk out of prison.
In Plano, an affluent suburb of Dallas, a little girl played on a merry-go-round while her mother watched her brother play soccer.
A convicted child molester abducted and murdered the little girl, then participated in the massive search after she went missing.
He was out of prison on parole.
Yet another ex-con, known as the Austin Choke Rapist, strangled and raped a 16-year-old former Miss Teen Houston contestant.
The parole board had released him six months earlier. He had served only eight years of a 156-year sentence for choking 33 college students unconscious before raping them.
Every 20 minutes in Houston, a paroled convict ransacked a home, assaulted a neighbor, stole a car, or committed some other crime.
No one was immune. Not even the district attorney.
Thieves stole his car. Sex offenders exposed themselves to his daughterânot once, but twice.
You didnât have to be a genius to see a pattern here.
A violent ex-con serves a fraction of his sentence. The parole board sets him free. Within a few days, he unleashes murder and mayhem.
This is the story of the parole of one of those notorious ex-cons: the Broomstick Killer, the most sadistic serial killer in Texas history.
I pulled out my reporterâs notebook. My law enforcement sources opened their case files. We sat down to talk.
And you can listen to our journey into darkness.
Parnell McNamara:
He was the devil himself. I mean, he was the epitome of a cold-hearted, heartless, evil, dirty son of a bitch.
Robert Riggs:
Thatâs the voice of Parnell McNamara, a Texas lawman from a long line of U.S. marshals.
When I first met McNamara and his brother Mike, I felt like I was back in the Old West.
The McNamaras were on the trail of the most sadistic serial killer in Texas history: Kenneth Allen McDuff.
And I was right behind them, uncovering how McDuff got out of prison on parole.
McDuff drove hundreds of miles, day and night, searching for his prey: petite women who could not fight back.
Parnell McNamara:
She was an accountant. She was a beautiful, sweet person. She had been to church that night and had stopped to wash her new sports car.
Robert Riggs:
McDuff spotted 28-year-old Colleen Reed at a self-service car wash in Austin shortly after Christmas 1991.
He circled the car wash. He watched her through his dead, shark-like eyes. He drove his big tan Thunderbird coupe into a wash bay and slipped up behind her.
Parnell McNamara:
Most all of his victims were, for whatever reason, brunette, and they were small females that he could easily manhandle. Some of them he would be able to pick up by the throat and get their feet off the ground, where they couldnât fight him.
Robert Riggs:
Neighbors heard a shrill scream and car doors slam. They saw McDuff and his accomplice speed away.
When police arrived, they found Colleenâs keys in the ignition, her purse on the seat, and soap still dripping from her car.
In a split second, Colleen Reed vanished, never to be seen alive again.
Gary LaVergne, author of Bad Boy from Rosebud: The Murderous Life of Kenneth Allen McDuff, recalls the impact of Colleen Reedâs murder.
Gary LaVergne:
Austin had never had torture, kidnapping, torture, brutalization by a serial sexual sadist. It was something that you might have heard about in California or in New York or someplace, but not in Austin, not even in Texas.
Texas has a lot of gun violence and so forth. But this wasnât even that. This was just pure brutality. And when it was made public, it traumatized the city.
Robert Riggs:
It was during that time period that you could pick up the paper on any day or turn on the television and somewhereâHouston, Dallas, particularly Houstonâthe lead story was a stranger-on-stranger crime, horrific violence. There were even women dragged out of traffic, stopped at lights. And the tagline would always be, âThey were out on parole.â
Describe that climate back at the time. What was going on? Because Texas had a law-and-order reputation, but criminals were having a field day.
Gary LaVergne:
From a political science standpoint, it was a surreal time. You had the conservative view that government spends too much and is too big. Then you had the federal case, the Ruiz case, in which a federal judge basically took control of the Texas prison system and said, âYouâre unconstitutionally overcrowded.â
The judge basically said, âYou can either build prisons or you can relieve that overcrowding.â The only way the State of Texas could do that was through parole.
Thousands upon thousands of people who were once in prison were let out. At first, the con artists and the nonviolent criminals were set free.
Robert Riggs:
Yeah. And then they get to the bottom of the barrel.
Gary LaVergne:
Then they get to the bottom of the barrel, and now youâre dealing with rapists and murderers and people who, before the Furman case that turned all death-row inmates into lifers, were eligible for parole.
No one believed back in the 1970s, when Furman v. Georgia happened, that we would be crazy enough to parole someone who was once on death row. But thatâs what happened.
Robert Riggs:
Hereâs the backstory.
I learned that the parole board had released 63 former death-row inmates. The correct number turned out to be 85.
Triple killer Kenneth Allen McDuff was among them.
But another triple killer on the list drew all the attention and outrage: Leonardo Lopez, convicted of capital murder for executing three sheriffâs deputies.
Robert Riggs:
Do you remember your shock?
Ted Lyon:
I was infuriated. I wasnât shocked. I was just outraged. I couldnât believe they would let those kind of people out.
Robert Riggs:
Senator Ted Lyon, chairman of the Senate Criminal Justice Committee, obtained the list of death-row inmates, gave it to me, and urged me to make it public.
Leonardo Lopez and his accomplice committed the Trinity River massacre in 1971. They took five sheriffâs deputies hostage and drove them to the banks of the Trinity River in Dallas at night.
They executed three deputies, gravely wounded a fourth, and the fifth deputy narrowly escaped gunfire.
The massacre spawned the biggest manhunt in Texas since Bonnie and Clyde.
The murders were personal for Senator Lyon. Very personal.
Lyon left the Senate in 1993. Three decades later, we sat down in his law office to discuss the case.
Robert Riggs:
You were familiar with the Lopez case. Just tell us, how bad was it?
Ted Lyon:
I was a young police officer in Mesquite, Texas. I think I was about 21 years old. I had just become a police officer, and I happened to work with one of the sheriffâs deputies in Dallas. The sheriffâs deputies would come out here as investigators. If they had to serve a warrant or something like that, normally they would get local help or come by the station.
One of those officers who was killedâI had actually worked with him on a case. So it hit the news like a ton of bricks.
Robert Riggs:
Back in those days, Texas politicians talked tough on crime. They passed dozens of anti-crime bills.
But they rejected building more prisons to relieve overcrowding. County sheriffs could not transfer convicted criminals to the overcrowded state prisons.
Riots broke out.
Republican Governor Bill Clements, a Texas oilman, responded by opening the prison floodgates.
No one saw the crime wave coming.
Ted Lyon:
It was inconceivable. They said they were for law and order, but they really werenât. All they cared about was the bottom line and the budget.
They didnât want to raise taxes, and they had to raise taxes to build the prison cells that were necessary. It was all about that. It was all about this: âWeâre not going to raise taxes.â They campaigned on that.
Then, when they got into office, they found out, âOh, my God, weâve got this problem with the prison system. Weâre just going to have to let these people out. It doesnât matter who they are.â That was what happened.
Robert Riggs:
The governor appointed members of the parole board. It was a plum political job. It required no criminal justice experience at all.
The board released 150 inmates a dayâ750 a week. They claimed the board was not under political pressure. It was just an unspoken quota.
It worked for a while, until they ran out of hot-check writers and petty criminals. Then the parole board scraped the bottom of the barrel.
Thatâs where they found the two triple killers, Leonardo Lopez and Kenneth McDuff.
The parole board also scraped the bottom of cell blocks called administrative segregation, or Ad Segâa prison within a prison reserved for the most dangerous inmates.
The first time I walked inside an Ad Seg unit, the angry screaming and shouting reminded me of a pen full of vicious pit bulls.
Ad Seg is a prison unit within a maximum-security prison. Guards wore raincoats to protect themselves against flying spit, urine, and feces.
Author Gary LaVergne recalls going inside to interview a mass murderer.
Gary LaVergne:
Whatâs really scary is when you go out into the general population of any of the other prisons. I went down to Administrative Segregation, High Security Administrative Segregation.
Robert Riggs:
The prison within a prison.
Gary LaVergne:
The prison for the prisoners, exactly. And that was scary. I was glad to get out of there.
Robert Riggs:
When Ad Seg inmates received parole, guards locked them in handcuffs and leg irons, drove them in caged prison vans to the nearest bus station in the dead of night, and handed them a bus ticket to freedom.
Robert Riggs:
What did it say about life to you at the time, the value of life?
Ted Lyon:
It was horrible. The most hypocritical person in the world is the person who saysâyou know, in Danteâs Divine Inferno, there are seven layers of hell in this book, and each layer gets hotter and hotter. At the very bottom of hell, thereâs a place hotter than any other circle. Itâs not a circle; itâs a special place. Itâs the hottest place in hell, and itâs for the political and religious hypocrites.
So, in the 13th century, probably when he wrote that book, he realized what kind of people those were. And thatâs what kind of people were serving on that parole board at that time. They were political hypocrites.
Robert Riggs:
Senator Lyon summoned parole board members to a hearing in the wake of my televised news report.
The parole board had not notified the Dallas County sheriff or district attorney that Lopez was up for parole. Otherwise, they would have filed a formal protest to block the release of the triple killer.
Inside the red granite Capitol building, built in 1885 using inmate labor, Senator Lyon called the hearing to order on April 9, 1991.
Hearing clerk:
The Justice Committee will come to order. The clerk will call the roll.
Robert Riggs:
Lyon tore into the two parole board members who voted to free Lopez, especially Douglas Jeu, the only member who interviewed Lopez face-to-face before approving the triple killer for parole.
Senator Ted Lyon:
If you murder three police officers in Texas, all youâre going to have to do is serve 16 years and youâll be out free. Why is that in the best interest of society?
Douglas Jeu:
Mr. Chairman, personally, I share the same sentiments that you have.
Senator Ted Lyon:
Well, youâre the one who let him out and signed the release, and I want to know why. Donât give me any bull about your sentiments. I want to know why heâs out. When a guy kills three police officers, and youâre the person who did it, you tell me why itâs in the best interest of our society.
Douglas Jeu:
I follow the guidelines set out by the law, telling me what to do. One of the main considerations I make as a board member is whether this person will be a danger to society if released into society.
Robert Riggs:
According to Lopezâs prison disciplinary record, there was no sign of rehabilitation.
A formal evaluation indicated that Lopez probably would not make it outside prison, in what convicts called the free world.
Yet Ron Givens, a former member of the legislature appointed to the parole board by Governor Clements, argued that Lopez had been rehabilitated.
Grilled by Senator Lyon, Givens made a stunning admission.
Senator Ted Lyon:
How bad do people have to be? How many people would he have to kill before you wouldnât let him out?
Ron Givens:
Crude as it might be, Senator, we cannot keep everyone. If we see ten people, we are letting eight of them go, Senator. Iâm going to say the things no one wants to hear. The problem is we cannot keep everyone we need to keep. If we could do that, this would be a perfect world, and there is no way I would have let this man out.
For lack of a better word, we are raking the bottom of the barrel, Senator. We must let these people go every day. We must let these people go. We have no choice, Senator.
James Granberry:
My name is James H. Granberry. Iâm representing the Board of Pardons and Paroles, and I am currently serving as chairman of the Board of Pardons and Paroles.
Robert Riggs:
James Granberry, a dentist from Lubbock in West Texas, had been appointed to the parole board two years earlier by Republican Governor Bill Clements.
Granberry had made a name for himself as the mayor of Lubbock during the recovery from a deadly tornado. His political credentials included an unsuccessful run for governor as a Republican.
Robert Riggs:
Then I attended hearings, and James Granberry, the chairman of the parole board, would always dismiss any criticism by saying, âWell, we donât have a crystal ball.â That was his favorite phrase. But they were model prisoners. I remember you and I talking about how that just didnât make any sense.
Ted Lyon:
They werenât model prisoners. They were just running them out. They were just letting them out. Those guys were not model prisoners. They were murderers.
Robert Riggs:
Itâs been 30 years since that hearing. Lyon still remains angry.
Ted Lyon:
One of the people who was running the system, who made this decision, was a former prosecutor from Dallas County, and he knew how bad these people were. But they just let them out, and the state failed tremendously.
Thatâs what you always worry about with these political hypocrites: They say one thing to the people, but you need to watch what they do.
Robert Riggs:
Because Texas has a law-and-order image and reputation, but this was anything but that.
Ted Lyon:
The most liberal person in government would never have done what these people did. This was intentional, and it was done knowingly and consciously because they knew exactly whom they were letting out. They knew it.
They had people in the office who were former prosecutors and knew just how bad these people were. To this day, I still donât understand it, and I talked to them back then.
Robert Riggs:
One month after the hearing, James Granberry abruptly resigned from the parole board. He left the chairmanship with four years remaining on his term.
He claimed his decision was not influenced by Senator Lyonâs criticism.
We didnât know at the time of the hearing you just heard that Granberry played a key role in the release of that other triple killer I mentioned earlier in this episode.
His name: Kenneth Allen McDuff, the Broomstick Killer.