Do Murderous Roots Lie Within Your Family Tree?

By Robert Riggs

What You Will Learn

It was called the “Ride Murder.”

The bullet-riddled body of an unidentified seaman from the Port of Houston, Texas, was found dumped in a ditch a few miles away.

HELP US FIND THIS MAN’S FAMILY

Two men and a woman used a “honey pot” trap to lure the seaman into their car to rob him.

It was one of the most sensational murder trials ever brought in East Texas.

School children paraded through the county jail on macabre field trips to get a look at the accused killers.

One of the defendants, who had already killed a traveling salesman using a similar “honey pot” ploy, sat behind bars drawing sketches about romantic encounters. 

Decades later, veteran criminal investigator Louis Fawcett was conducting genealogical research about his family tree.

Imagine his shock when Fawcett who had spent 43 years hunting down criminals, discovered that the trigger man in the “Ride Murder” was his uncle.


If you have information about the identity of the murdered seaman, please CONTACT US.

What You Will Learn

  • How a veteran investigator discovered a family connection to the Ride Murder.
  • What happened to the unidentified seaman and how he was lured into a robbery.
  • Why identifying the victim and learning more about the ship remain open questions in the episode.

Stay One Step Ahead of Danger

withStories to Keep You Safe

Recognize the warning signs before you become a victim.

Get Robert Riggs’ newsletter for reporting on violent crime, AI threats, and hidden dangers—plus practical steps to help protect yourself and your family.

Books by Robert Riggs

Texas Crime Stories: Blood & Betrayal, by Robert Riggs

Latest publication

Texas Crime Stories

Blood & Betrayal

Riding Herd on the Lawless ¡ Vol. 1

Go inside the cases Texas will never forget.

A preacher with a deadly secret. A mother whose crime shocked a community. A death-row phone call that exposed a prison scandal. Robert Riggs takes you behind the headlines through firsthand accounts, investigations, and the pursuit of justice.

Buy the Book
Read the Story

The bullet-riddled body of an unidentified seaman from the Port of Houston, Texas was found dumped in a ditch a few miles away.

Two men and a woman used a “honey pot” trap to lure the seaman into their car to rob him.

It was one of the most sensational murder trials ever brought in East, Texas.

School children paraded through the county jail on macabre field trips to get a look at the accused killers.

One of the defendants who had already killed a traveling salesman using a similar “honey pot” ploy sat behind bars drawing sketches about romantic encounters.

Decades later, veteran criminal investigator Louis Fawcett was conducting genealogical research about his family tree.

Imagine his shock when Fawcett who had spent 43 years hunting down criminals, discovered that the trigger man in the Ride Murder was his uncle.

This is a True Crime Reporter™ EXTRA from Dallas, Texas.

Investigative reporter Robert Riggs unfolds another story from inside the crime scene tape.

It was called the Ride Murder.

It was one of the most sensational murder trials ever brought in Liberty County, Texas.

This is a True Crime Reporter™ EXTRA from Dallas, Texas.

Hello I’m Robert Riggs with another story from inside the crime scene tape.

Imagine the shock when a veteran law enforcement officer who spent 43 years hunting down criminals, discovered the trigger man in the Ride Murder was his uncle.

Robert Riggs

As a lawman, I mean, is this something that's kind of eaten at you?

After all these years of enforcing the law and bringing people to justice

Louis Fawcett

Yes, it does from because of the victims, you know, you get justice, hopefully, through the criminal justice system with the family doesn't ever get any justice. They never have any peace. Because of that death. And this is one of the things that troubles me about this particular case

Louis Fawcett was a renowned fugitive hunter for the Texas Prison System and served on task forces for the FBI and U.S. Marshals Service.

As a kid, he heard stories that his uncle was a killer. So he recently started digging.

Louis Fawcett

My hobby is genealogy. And so I took an interest in this early on. And in 2001, I was in Liberty research, my family tree, and quite frankly, looking up, mom, and I was talking to the people there in the library. And I heard a voice say, Sir, I remember this story I was there. Well, that got my attention. And I turned it was an older lady. And she said, Yes. He said, I went up to the jail when this happened. My class did she that was 11 years old.

Fawcett’s search led him to a murder committed on February 12th of 1935.

The bullet-riddled, partially clad body of an unidentified man was found in a muddy ditch thirty-one miles from the Port of Houston.

Louis Fawcett

I want to know who this guy was. I want to get him returned to his family, or at least get some resolution we can get a headstone for his grave. Because it's important to me and it’s important to the victims of crime to be able to have some resolution.

The murder victim was a seaman without a name or birthplace.

Stocky build. Between 28 and 30 years of age. 155 pounds. Five feet nine inches tall.

A scar three-fourths of an inch long behind his right ear. A growth the size of a quarter located an inch above his forehead.

Found in his underwear, wearing a shirt, one glove, and a tie tightly drawn under his shirt into his mouth.

His body smelled of liquor.

Louis Fawcett

Well, the fact they didn't know who he was, was big. They actually took his body and laid it out, probably in the morgue. And people were able to come by and visit and part of those people who came by and visit was a class of, of young people from the school.

The death certificate ruled the cause of death as shot with a 32 caliber automatic hand gun, 5 times.

Twice in the right side lower ribs.

Once in the right side shoulder blade.

Once in the right side of the neck.

And once in the right temple by an unknown party or parties.

Louis Fawcett

According to the newspaper reports again his name was Mancuso and I thought at first that was a first name, apparently that's a last name. Mancuso? Yeah. And he originally came from Buenos Aires. The ship was flagged in Italy. And that's all it was ever learned about him.

The murder remained a mystery, a cold case for two years.

In 1937 Richard Palmer summoned the Liberty County Sheriff to Austin, Texas.

The 26-year old Palmer was being held there on a life sentence for a similar “ride murder” of a Houston salesman.

Palmer confessed to the murder of the unidentified man and named John Wesley “Blackie” Fawcett, as his accomplice.

Then 25-year-old Blackie Fawcett was the uncle of the lawman Louis Fawcett.

Palmer said the victim was a seaman named Mancuso. They met him at a Houston dice game. He appeared to have some money.

Louis Fawcett

In fact that they met him. They put him in a car. I think they recruited this female, obviously, to have a female involved with him, right? Lure bait. Yeah, she was young. She was in her early 20s. And so were they that matter. But they met, they bought alcohol, they bought a lot of alcohol. And it will begin to drive around drinking and partying and talking.

Palmer told the Sheriff that they plied the seaman with whiskey as they drove around.

A witness told police that a mystery woman with red hair was in the back seat wrapped in a quilt beside a man who was quote, “beastly drunk or dead.”

Officers found the mystery woman, 22-year-old Mrs. Nellie Scoville in Oklahoma and arrested her for murder.

They also arrested Palmer and Blackie Fawcett for murder.

The pair became the subject of morbid school field trips to the county jail.

Louis Fawcett

And they came in and they actually saw my uncle and they saw that the Palmer guy and Palmer was apparently an artist, prison art. They do a lot of art and I don't know if he actually generated the work but according to a witness that I met early on in my genealogy research he did draw and he had drawn two pictures and she had those pictures and my uncle had signed it and Palmer had signed it. She was able to provide me with a copy.

Palmer’s murder trial got off to a rocky start when someone cried out that Palmer was trying to escape.

Texas Rangers pulled their guns. Deputies rushed to the exits. Officers crashed into the Sheriff’s office only to find Palmer seated calmly in a chair facing his attorney.

Nellie Scoville the mystery woman was the star witness in Palmer’s murder trial.

A hush fell over the packed courtroom as she gave a gruesome description of how she accompanied Palmer and Fawcett on the “death ride” and saw them throw the body out of the car.

She claimed Fawcett was the trigger man.

But in a moment of courtroom theater, Fawcett’s defense attorney Price Daniel an up-and-coming politician summoned a slender dark-haired man before the witness stand.

Price Daniel asked Scoville to identify the man. She testified that he was “Blackie” Fawcett. But he was a ringer.

Louis Fawcett

My uncle had jet black hair, thus they called him Blackie. So they brought in a guy that was a wholesale grocer. And the female picked him out as one of the killers. And of course, they got my uncle off.

Palmer was found guilty and received a life sentence for murder.

When we come back. Prosecutors keep trying to send Black Fawcett to the electric chair.

Commercial

If you like our True Crime Reporter™ podcast please recommend it to your friends and join our True Crime Community by signing up through the link in our show notes.

Now back to our story.

Prosecutors were determined to send Fawcett to the Texas electric chair, known as “Old Sparky.”

Fawcett had confessed to riding around with Palmer and the seaman. Said they got drunk and decided to rob him. Fawcett claimed Palmer was the triggerman and divided $140 taken from the seaman’s pocket after the shooting.

But Fawcett later repudiated the confession and claimed he signed it out of fear of bodily harm from officers.

The judge declared a mistrial when the Sheriff disclosed in his testimony that Fawcett had served four months in the Louisiana prison system for auto theft.

Then in a second murder trial, Fawcett got off with a hung jury. After deliberating for 70 hours the 12 member jury deadlocked.

Eleven voted to send Fawcett to the electric chair.

A lone juror held out for a 25-year sentence.

The judge dismissed the jury and sent them home.

In a third and final murder trial, the jury found Fawcett not guilty.

Fawcett took the stand in his own defense.

Fawcett’s mother and other family members testified that he was home at the time of the murder. And a police chief confirmed that Fawcett had stopped by to see him.

Nellie Scoville’s misidentification in the earlier murder trial clearly influenced the jury’s decision to acquit Fawcett.

They deliberated less than two hours.

Wesley “Blackie” Fawcett walked out of the Liberty County courthouse a free man on November 9th of 1938.

A year after the trial, his alleged accomplice, Richard A. Palmer twice convicted of murder was killed in a predawn mystery stabbing at the Retrieve Prison Farm outside Houston.

The lifer was stabbed a half dozen times as inmates lined up to work in the fields.

He staggered into the prison hospital where he died without saying a word.

The knife was never found. The inmates sealed their lips in a code of prison silence.

Was the prison hit payback for snitching on Blackie Fawcett?

Lou Fawcett doesn’t know but believes his uncle got away with the Ride Murder.

He wants to find the victim’s final resting place and identify him for the family he never came home to see.

Robert Riggs

You’ve been out the cemeteries and you have found in some plots, multiple people buried in a grave, and then you found a civil war casket,tell us about it.

Louis Fawcett:

Yeah, that was I was shocked that because I had talked to some people that had had graves there exhumed in this particular cemetery. And I won't mention which one it was. But this individual told me that there was, they had discovered this one grave, I was really concerned about that it had already been dug up twice. And then on one of those occasions, that they pulled the casket out of the grave, and it was an iron casket. And it was a glass face over this, that you could see the body. Well, they accidentally broke the glass. When they did the air got into and the body was dissolved and returned back into dust. So I had to mark that went off the list, but there's still so many more just in that particular one cemetery. So I look for anybody that might hoping that they might have put the date of the death on a tombstone or mark or something, but I was able to find his death certificate, which didn't have anything in information only said that he was killed and how he was killed. And and that was about it.

Robert Riggs

And you believe your uncle got away with murder. What happened after that with him and his life?

Louis Fawcett

Well, in 1957 He had a drinking problem. And he was in a little apartment house. He woke up our guests in the morning and CeCe he said according to witnesses there that they did hear from him, and that something just didn't feel right. And He lit a cigarette and house exploded. What had happened was aghast yet by the better by the chair had been left home. And when he did that cigarette, he made it to the door and able to tell the firemen there that he tried to light a cigarette and it blew up.

Robert Riggs

If someone has ideas or suggestions, email us at fan at True Crime reporter.com That's fan at true crime reporter and once again, tell us his last name again where he was from?

Louis Fawcett:

Mancuso from Buenos Aires. The ship was from Italy. I have no more details about the ship or about the victim.

Robert Riggs:

Lou would like your help, please reach out to fan at true crime reporter if you've got any suggestions ideas, tips He's very interested we'll pursue them. Thank You.

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the Ride Murder?

The Ride Murder was a sensational Liberty County, Texas case involving the killing of an unidentified seaman from the Port of Houston. Two men and a woman used a “honey pot” ploy to lure him into a car and rob him.

Who is Louis Fawcett?

Fawcett is a veteran criminal investigator who spent 43 years hunting criminals. While researching his family tree, he discovered that the trigger man in the Ride Murder was his uncle.

How did Louis Fawcett learn his uncle was involved?

Fawcett was conducting genealogical research when he recognized that his uncle was the trigger man in the Ride Murder, a case he had encountered as a lawman.

What information about the unidentified seaman is shared?

At the episode’s end, Fawcett identifies his uncle as Mancuso from Buenos Aires and says the ship was from Italy. He says he has no further details about the victim or ship.